Accurate measurement of power supply efficiency

Bernhard Erdl, Founder, President and Chief Developer of PULS Power, discusses power supply efficiency and why design engineers should be wary of relying on the efficiencies quoted in power supply data sheets.

Modern power supplies are characterised by claims of ever higher efficiencies, but can designers actually rely on the efficiency specifications stated in datasheets provided by manufacturers? How were the values determined, and can an end user make their own measurements and what would be involved in doing so?

More and more system designers are realising that the efficiency of a power supply has a direct influence on its reliability. It is essential - especially in the case of convection-cooled devices - to balance the required dimensions for the power supply against the reliability or end product lifetime. Without additional ventilation, heat can only be dissipated to a limited degree and the designer of a power supply must be very careful to achieve the lowest possible heat generation. Other essential system elements will also benefit from low power losses and minimal heat generation from the power supply.

All power supply manufacturers strive to design high-efficiency products. This article will help users determine efficiency accurately and thus the power losses of a power supply and not have to rely completely on data sheets with scant or sometimes optimistic information.

The following five recommendations should be given highest priority when measuring efficiency and have proved to be essential in practice. They are explained in more detail in this article.

  • Use precision meters: If possible, power analysers or highly accurate wattmeters
  • Ensure proper cabling when setting up the measurement and that you are measuring the correct voltage
  • When taking AC measurements, always use an electronic AC source if available
  • Avoid EMC interference from the device under test
  • Consider temperature and time influences

Efficiency is a figure that helps designers carry out a proper comparison of different power supplies. However, system designers and users of power supplies are even more interested in the heat which remains in the power supply - i.e. the power losses. Since these power losses cannot be electrically measured in a direct manner, one can only consider the difference between input and output power.

Currently most efficiency values lie at around 95 per cent - this corresponds to a loss of 5 per cent. However small measurement errors in the input and output power lead to large errors when calculating power loss: if there is a measurement error of just 0.5 per cent, i.e. a total of 1 per cent, the power loss calculation would be wrong by 20 per cent (see diagram 1).

Image

It is also important to keep in mind that seemingly small differences in efficiency mean a big difference in power losses. The values for modern power supplies lie between 92 and 95 per cent. The user might have the impression that one or two per cent of difference wouldn't play a big role. However, this is a misconception, because it is not the absolute value of efficiency but rather the difference from the ideal value of 100 per cent that matters most.

As an example for comparable power supplies with 48V/5A output: The PULS QS10 introduced in 2005 has an efficiency of 92.0 per cent. 10 years later, the PULS CP10 is available with an efficiency of 95.5 per cent. At first glance, the difference of "just" 3.5 per cent doesn't seem to be a big improvement. However, the power losses of the CP10 have been reduced by 41 per cent when compared with the QS10 model.

This means that at high efficiencies, even small increases produce a significant reduction in no-load losses. With increasing efficiencies, measurement accuracy keeps gaining in importance, as otherwise it would be impossible to determine no load losses properly.

Determining efficiency accurately and avoiding errors

The closer the developer gets to that perfect efficiency of 100 per cent, the harder it becomes to measure accurately. Absolute measurement precision is therefore essential to give an accurate statement about no-load losses in a power supply. Many errors could be avoided by good preparation and professional measurement. The most common sources of error are:

  • Incorrect measurement principle due to unsuitable meters
  • Inaccurate meters
  • Faulty measurement setup
  • Neglecting environmental conditions

Multimeter, wattmeter or power analyser - which is the (measurement) tool of choice?

There are a number of measuring instruments which are used for the determination of efficiency. However, the measurement tolerances and the capabilities of measuring instruments when measuring various signals (AC or DC) vary considerably.

Multimeter: Accurate multimeters do a great job measuring the voltage and current of purely DC inputs and outputs. The voltage can be measured with high precision directly at the input and output of the power supply. Many multimeters also have built-in ability to measure current, but this is usually too inaccurate (inaccuracy of 1 per cent or more) or it does not have sufficient measuring range (usually limited to 10A). Instead, the current should be measured by high-precision shunt resistors with 0.01 per cent tolerance. However the non-synchronous detection of values can be problematic because it leads to errors if fluctuating conditions are present.

Data loggers are even better for DC measurements. They consist of a single, usually highly accurate meter, which is used several times by multiplexing. In the same measuring range, the errors even cancel each other out and all values can be promptly recorded and evaluated quickly with a spreadsheet.

However, AC input power cannot be measured with multimeters or data loggers. It is a common mistake to assume that it is sufficient to measure the true RMS of the current and voltage and to multiply the two values to determine the input power. This calculation, however, determines the apparent power and not the real power which is crucial for the power losses. The measurement of AC input power, even with True RMS multimeters gives incorrect measurements and is an absolute no-go!

Wattmeters are used for measuring AC signals and offer the correct principle. The instantaneous values of current and voltage are multiplied and a mean value is calculated from these products - this corresponds to the physical definition of performance. However, most simple wattmeters have a high measurement inaccuracy (around 1 per cent). Moreover, frequently changing input or output currents (AC input, varying output load) cause additional measuring errors. Fluctuating values are thus difficult to interpret. Generally, only high-precision wattmeters should be used when measuring efficiency.

Power analyser: PULS uses power analysers to measure the efficiency of its power supplies (see image 1). The advantages of this are the high basic accuracy of 0.02 per cent, the correct measuring of active power, the simultaneous and thus synchronous measuring of input and output, and the direct display of power losses and efficiency. The downside of this method of measuring is the high purchase price involved. Nevertheless, the power analyser is the tool of choice for accurate determination of efficiency.

Image

Avoiding mistakes in the measurement setup: A precise and expensive power analyser may, however, not provide accurate results if mistakes were made during the measurement setup.

Correct wiring: All power losses that do not come from the device under test are not allowed to be included in the measurement! This is the main principle when it comes to correct wiring in the measurement setup, because every cable and every contact resistance causes additional power losses that may distort the measurement results. A proper four-pole measurement (Kelvin measurement) must have separate cables for the measurement of current and voltage (see image 2).

Image

Voltage source: Simple DC voltage supplies are sufficient for switch-mode power supplies with DC-input. For AC measurements, it is important to know that the internal resistance of the voltage source influences the measurement through the curve shape of the mains sine. In a 240W power supply without PFC, a difference of 0.4 per cent was measured between the soft power from an isolating regulating transformer and the hard power from an electronic AC source. This gives the most reproducible values and is therefore preferable.

Loads: Not only the power source, but also the load used must be stable and reproducible. The loads from power resistors are problematic because they don't draw a constant current. Electronic loads represent a defined and reproducible load for the device under test and even fluctuating transition resistances do not alter the current.

EMC interferences: Unshielded power supplies in the prototype stage can interfere with meters and/or can cause loads to fluctuate. Measurements should accept no signals with HF interference from meters. Additional filters, mostly inductors in the input lines, prevent these problems. Power losses should not be able to flow into the measurement. There should be no such problems when measuring clean, radio interference-suppressed power supplies.

Taking environmental conditions into consideration

In respect to environmental conditions, temperature plays a decisive role, because the power losses from a power supply are temperature dependent. The temperature of the components in a power supply is a crucial factor. The component temperature is the sum of ambient temperature and self-heating.

Temperature: The various components in the power supply react differently to temperature. In some essential elements an increase in temperature results in a reduction of power losses, and in other components it increases them. The NTCs used for limiting the input inrush current have a strong influence. Power supplies with such components have less power losses when running and in higher ambient temperatures (negative temperature coefficient), because at higher temperatures the increase of power loss is outweighed again by other essential elements (see diagram 2).

Image

Devices with an active input inrush current limiter display a more stable temperature behaviour. Here there is only a small increase in power loss from temperature (see diagram 3).

Image

When taking any efficiency measurement, the running time and the ambient temperature should be documented so that the results remain traceable.

Altitude and air pressure: Since cooling is done by air, the air pressure has an influence on self-heating. PULS has calculated how much additional heat is generated by components at a higher altitude: by approx. + 10degC at an altitude of 2000m above sea level and approx. + 20degC at 4000m. Humidity plays only a very minor role and can be neglected.

Sample distributions: Every component used in a power supply has tolerances and therefore not every device manufactured is the same. But to find genuine errors, PULS measures power losses very closely even during production - although this is not quite as accurate as in the laboratory. A mean value of 95.27 per cent with a deviation of +/-0.15 per cent was measured on a production batch of 200 devices of the model CP10 (see diagram 4).

Image

Requesting accurate efficiency specifications

Rather than designers having to carry out their own measurements it is obviously easier to rely on the manufacturer's specifications - assuming accurate measurements have been taken. Unfortunately, the datasheets for this very important characteristic often contain general statements, such as "up to x per cent efficiency". This is a best-case statement and actually just means that this value is not exceeded. For example, power losses at different mains voltages or loads are not mentioned. Therefore, users who want to know in more detail cannot avoid taking their own measurements. Or else they find another manufacturer who provides full and accurate specifications. But even then, they might feel more reassured if they take one last measurement themselves.

Learn more about PULS and its power supplies at www.pulspower.com.

PULS UK Ltd

Cranfield Innovation Centre
University Way
Cranfield
MK43 0BT
UNITED KINGDOM

+44 (0)1525 841001

sales@puls.co.uk

www.pulspower.com

More from PULS UK Ltd

Power decentralisation made easier

Posted 1 week ago

Ultra-compact, high-efficiency DIN-Rail power supplies revealed

Posted 3 months ago

DIN power rails: one-on-one video conferencing service

Posted 4 months ago

Decentralised Power supplies for Smart Manufacturing

Posted 5 months ago

PULS Power launches 500W waterproof ZeroCabinet power supply

Posted 5 months ago

Improving the efficiency of N+1 redundant power supplies

Posted 7 months ago

Ruggedised DIN-rail power supplies feature conformal coating

Posted 8 months ago

PULS launches Piano Mini 36W, 60W, 90W DIN-rail power supplies

Posted 1 year ago

PULS DIN-rail Power Supplies gain rail certification

Posted 1 year ago

Live demos of PULS DIN-rail power supplies and PoE injectors

Posted 1 year ago

24V 20A DC DIN-rail power supply with remote control of output

Posted 1 year ago

SmartFab Box records live power requirements, thermal conditions

Posted 1 year ago

DIN-rail power supply with IO-Link is ready for Industry 4.0

Posted 1 year ago

Benefits of capacitor-based uninterruptible power supplies

Posted 1 year ago

PULS DIN-rail power supplies come with long-term support

Posted 1 year ago

Compact, powerful and cost-effective DIN-rail power supply

Posted 1 year ago

High-reliability medical DIN rail power supplies from PULS

Posted 2 years ago

DIN-rail PoE injectors and DIN-rail power supplies at EDS 2018

Posted 2 years ago

PULS DIN-rail power supplies with conformal-coated PCBs

Posted 2 years ago

Reliable DIN rail power supplies: only pay for what you need

Posted 2 years ago

PULS CP power supplies available with internal decoupling

Posted 2 years ago

New eight-port DIN-rail PoE injectors from PULS

Posted 2 years ago

24V/10A DIN-rail power supply: 95 per cent efficiency, 39mm wide

Posted 5 years ago

PULS launches PIANO cost-efficient DIN-rail power supplies

Posted 5 years ago

DIN Rail Power Supplies: compact and affordable

Posted 6 years ago

PULS UK managing director named as John Tyrrell

Posted 7 years ago

PULS expands uninterruptible power supply range

Posted 7 years ago

High-voltage DC input power supplies meet new UL and IEC Regs

Posted 8 years ago

Free UK-based technical support for power supply customers

Posted 8 years ago

High-efficiency DIN-rail power supplies light two million LEDs

Posted 8 years ago

Energy-efficient step-down DC/DC converter generates less heat

Posted 9 years ago

PISA protection module safeguards PLCs and aids troubleshooting

Posted 9 years ago

30W DIN rail power supply is compact, efficient and economical

Posted 9 years ago

More technical articles
1 day ago
New UK Managing Director for HARTING Ltd
HARTING Ltd, the German electrical and electronic connector technology company, will be under new management from January 2021
1 day ago
UK machine builder responds to face mask demand
When a UK specialist in automation and machine building was asked to manufacture face mask machinery to help cope with the COVID-19 pandemic, it turned to NSK linear guides for some swift movement
1 day ago
Felt seals designed to protect iglidur plain bearings
igus has introduced new felt seals designed to protect iglidur plain bearings from the adverse effects of operation in environments where sand, dirt and abrasive dust is present
4 days ago
Zero tolerance towards hose re-ending says BFPA
Nigel Thomason, British Fluid Power Association Distributor Chairman, condemned hose re-ending across industry as the UK’s fluid power trade association launched its ‘Choose Q for Quality’ campaign highlighting BFPA Approved Quality Members
4 days ago
New laser micrometer offers greater flexibility
Micro-Epsilon has extended its optoCONTROL 2520 series of optical laser micrometers with a new version offering double the measuring range of its existing version
4 days ago
Self-adhesive gaskets certified for hygiene applications
EMKA has introduced new self-adhesive gaskets that are approved to hygiene standard VDI 6022
5 days ago
Online igus trade show attracts thousands of engineers
Digital engineering support during a pandemic: thousands have visited the igus online trade exhibition
5 days ago
Robotics Innovation Award Nominees 2020
The finalists in the 16th Award for Innovation and Entrepreneurship in Robotics & Automation (IERA) showcases the latest skills robots have acquired to assist humans at work
5 days ago
Guide to choosing the right cable clamp
The integration of electrical and electronic systems into machines and panels always involves addressing wiring, and considering things like strain relief, accessibility, routing, and security. Essentra Components has published a new guide which might prove helpful in these cases
6 days ago
Discover maxon’s new online trade fair
MachineBuilding.net readers can visit the virtual maxon booth to discover the company’s latest products. In addition to the newly announced MiniMACS6 master controller, visitors will find high torque BLDC motors as well as flat motors for robotics and an update on the Mars rover