Advantages of mechanical torque limiters over electronic types

Techdrives offers advice on how to select the right mechanical or pneumatic torque limiter for a given applications, and explains the advantages over limiting torque using electronic devices.

Some people today view mechanical torque limiters as old-fashioned and unnecessary, believing that electronic monitoring can meet the needs of machine protection and operator safety. However, what is actually needed is a device to prevent damage from accidental collisions that can lead to expensive downtime. There is also an increasing emphasis on operator safety, as EN ISO 13849-1 demands a higher level of protection than was acceptable before. In these cases the humble mechanical torque limiter remains the optimal answer because it disconnects the drive from the driven parts in a very short time.

Where there is a slow increase in load, for example due to damaged bearings or dirt contamination, electronic sensing can work well; there is time to stop the drive and the signal can be used as a preventative alarm. On the other hand, where the load increase is sudden, for example due to a misfeed or mechanical breakage, only a mechanical torque limiter can give protection. By introducing a disconnection between the motor and the driven load, the torque limiter takes much of the inertial energy out of the drive train. Indeed where the limiter can be positioned at low speed close to the output, practically all the kinetic energy can be disconnected, resulting in a greatly reduced possibility of damage or injury. Disconnection is not instantaneous; depending on the design and size of limiter it can take from single figures to tens of milliseconds. However, electronic systems cannot match this performance as they have to sense the overload and then apply a braking torque to bring the drive train to a stop. Therefore when it comes to achieving maximum protection and safety, mechanical torque limiters remain the only real answer.

Simple friction torque limiters drive using spring-loaded rubbing faces that connect to a driven wheel, often a plate wheel. These friction torque limiters are low cost, easy to adjust steplessly, and react very quickly to shock loads. They do not suit operation in oily environments, or under conditions of prolonged slippage, which introduces wear and the need for readjustment. Therefore they are best used at low speed, positioned close to the output. They are available in a wide range of rated torques from 1 to 23,000Nm.

Image
A higher consistency of release torque and the ability for operation in oily and dirty environments is met by stepping up to a ball or roller design of torque limiter. Both work by spring pressure, usually from disc-type springs that push together two plates. The plates have recesses for hardened balls or rollers and, when an overload occurs, the balls/rollers rise up out of their recesses and run in a track around the plates. Disconnection is not instantaneous, as the springs have to be compressed when the plates move apart. Ball designs require less separation and can be more sensitive, while roller designs are useful to avoid nuisance tripping on small torque variations, and for transmitting higher torques. The release action of ball and roller types of torque limiters gives an axial movement that can be detected by a micro switch or proximity switch, allowing the drive to be turned off.

Many variants are available based on the ball and roller principle. By positioning the rollers asymmetrically, re-engagement will always be in a synchronised angular position. Alternatively, multiple positions - such as every 180 or 60 degrees - are possible. The recesses can be machined to give different torques according to the direction of rotation. Models are available for in-line transmission with shaft couplings, and offset with narrow or wide gears and pulleys. These popular designs are to some extent a European standard product and have ratings from 2 to 12,000Nm.

Image
Reversing and reciprocating drives in the packaging industry have triggered further development of ball-type torque limiters with backlash-free variants. These have also found use with index tables, printing machines and machine tools. The internal structure of the torque limiter is modified to remove splines and generally a locking bush connection to the shaft is used. A higher degree of sensitivity is possible too, by using disc springs that have a negative spring rate; as the drive plates begin to separate on overload, the spring force decreases and the release time becomes very fast indeed. Such torque limiters are more complex and costly but offer the highest levels of protection. They are typically available for torques up to 750Nm and can be supplied with stainless steel construction for severe environments.

Generally mechanical torque limiters are set to release at the highest torque required by the drive plus a service factor. In many machines the starting torque is often the highest torque. Setting the torque limiter above this level is necessary to prevent tripping on start-up, but may result in a lack of sensitivity during the normal working part of a machine cycle. The ability to easily adjust the release torque during a cycle, or perhaps for a different product running on a machine, is an advantage contributing to a higher degree of protection. Electronic monitoring can easily handle different levels of torque but, as mentioned above, does not give the disconnection. The torque limiter solution to this problem is to use pneumatic actuation.

Image
Pneumatic torque limiters are effectively clutches with the ability to disconnect a drive. A pneumatic piston replaces the springs of mechanical limiters, and the release torque is directly proportional to the air pressure applied. Factory air pressures up to 6bar are used and this gives the ability to vary the release torque through a work cycle, or to quickly set a new release torque for a new machine set-up. Variable torques can be set for coilers and uncoilers proportional to the reel diameter. These roller-based designs synchronise input to output and give release torques in a range of 7 to 30,000Nm.

Over the years mechanical torque limiters have been developed to suit a number of market niches. Linear force limiters trip when a set force is exceeded either in tension or compression and are frequently used as gearbox torque arms. A pneumatic friction design suits simple tensioning applications, as the pneumatic cylinder automatically compensates for wear on the friction linings. Roller types can be supplied to give an overload signal without disconnecting the drive, which is a useful feature where the load might otherwise fall. Every application has individual requirements for protection and sensitivity. Where operator safety is a factor, higher standards are needed and advice from experienced suppliers is recommended. The new safety standard EN ISO 13849-1 requires machine designers to re-assess hazards, although, as a standard related to control systems, it does not specifically deal with torque limiting. Nevertheless the review process may identify torque limiters as a means of achieving higher safety levels.

Mechanical torque limiters are today available in widely different forms to suit practically all types of machinery. The level of protection achieved depends on the sensitivity and repeatability of the torque limiter. Compared to electronic torque monitoring, mechanical torque limiters offer the important advantage of disconnection where the inertial energy on the drive side is isolated from the output, reducing damage and improving safety. A complete range of torque limiters manufactured by ComInTec is shown on the Techdrives website www.techdrives.co.uk, or follow the links in the text above.

Lenze Selection (a Division of Lenze Ltd)

6 Abbey Court Road
Priory Business Park
BEDFORD
MK44 3WH
UNITED KINGDOM

+44 (0)1234 753201

sales.uk@lenze-selection.com

https://www.lenze-selection.com/en-gb

More from Lenze Selection (a Division of Lenze Ltd)

‘Braking’ with the past!

Posted 3 months ago

Your partner for mechanical drive train projects

Posted 6 months ago

Spring-applied brake approved for functional safety applications

Posted 1 year ago

Modular signal towers are brighter, with new buzzer technology

Posted 4 years ago

New brake options for cranes and hoists

Posted 5 years ago

INTORQ brochure: brakes for lift applications

Posted 5 years ago

INTORQ spring-applied brakes with low-cost speed sensor option

Posted 5 years ago

New torque limiters suit high powers and speeds

Posted 5 years ago

Performance with economy from curved jaw shaft couplings

Posted 5 years ago

How to select gearboxes for servo motors

Posted 6 years ago

Economical mounting of torque limiters on gearbox input shafts

Posted 6 years ago

Free guide to electromagnetic clutches and brakes

Posted 6 years ago

Friction torque limiters: low-cost protection for machinery

Posted 6 years ago

Right-angle gearboxes for servo motors

Posted 6 years ago

New signal light with seven colours in one lens

Posted 6 years ago

New Design Guide for efficient motors, drives and gears

Posted 6 years ago

Servo-driven actuators replace pneumatic & hydraulic cylinders

Posted 6 years ago

Catalogue details Panasonic MINAS servo motors and drives

Posted 6 years ago

Phase shifting gearboxes suit emergency drives

Posted 6 years ago

New light bars: energy-efficient machine lighting

Posted 7 years ago

Customised gearboxes take drives around a corner

Posted 7 years ago

Rugged coupling suits outdoor use

Posted 7 years ago

Universal joint FAQs answered by Techdrives

Posted 7 years ago

New rack & pinion system achieves micron accuracy

Posted 7 years ago

Techdrives at Southern Manufacturing in February

Posted 7 years ago

Linear force limiter prevents overloads

Posted 7 years ago

Powerful new linear actuators enter screw jack territory

Posted 7 years ago

New packaged torque limiter for geared motors

Posted 7 years ago

High-integrity spring-applied brakes

Posted 7 years ago

New website provides quick access to drive components

Posted 7 years ago

Linear motion FAQs answered by Techdrives

Posted 7 years ago

Range of curved jaw shaft couplings expanded

Posted 8 years ago

Slip-free holding brakes for surgical instrument

Posted 8 years ago

Extended range of Panasonic brushless geared motors

Posted 8 years ago

New spring-applied brake is tough

Posted 8 years ago

Shaft couplings, collars and universal joints in new catalogue

Posted 8 years ago

Pre-set torque limiters save time in machine building

Posted 8 years ago

High-torque electromagnetic clutches suit difficult environments

Posted 8 years ago

Arcoflex range of metal disc shaft couplings is extended

Posted 8 years ago

Bi-stable electromagnetic clutch is safe and energy-efficient

Posted 8 years ago

Linear actuators used to test railway point changers

Posted 8 years ago

Compact brushless geared motors with accurate speed holding

Posted 8 years ago

LED signal towers for food machinery and washdown conditions

Posted 9 years ago

Spring-applied high-torque brakes with IP66 protection

Posted 9 years ago

Compact servo drives and motors offer higher performance

Posted 9 years ago

Brake systems for lifts, cranes & hoists

Posted 9 years ago

Worm-geared motors are easy to select and install

Posted 9 years ago

Normally-on spring-applied holding brakes for wind turbines

Posted 9 years ago

Techdrives to exhibit at Drives & Controls 2012

Posted 9 years ago

Animations show how ETP hydraulic locking bushes work

Posted 9 years ago

Patlite BSV voice annunciators are MP3 compatible

Posted 9 years ago

Vogel bevel helical gearboxes suit servo applications

Posted 9 years ago

Linear-Mech MR geared rotary actuators from Techdrives

Posted 10 years ago

Servomech high-precision ball screws from Techdrives

Posted 10 years ago

Servomech solar tracking actuators from Techdrives

Posted 10 years ago

How to specify spring-applied brakes

Posted 10 years ago

Patlite type RLR rotating beacon suits harsh environments

Posted 10 years ago

Intorq caliper brakes for safety-critical applications

Posted 10 years ago

Modular metal disc couplings are versatile and cost-effective

Posted 10 years ago

LED light bars are sealed to IP69K

Posted 10 years ago

B10d lifetimes for INTORQ spring-applied electromagnetic brakes

Posted 11 years ago

Cool-running Patlite LED lighting for industrial machinery

Posted 11 years ago

Locking bushes clamp workholding fixtures for aerospace project

Posted 11 years ago

Vogel phase shifting gearboxes available from Techdrives

Posted 11 years ago

FIAMA position sensors now available from Techdrives

Posted 11 years ago

Mönninghoff electromagnetic tooth clutches in the UK

Posted 11 years ago

Quick-locking bushes provide for rapid shaft/hub adjustments

Posted 11 years ago

Spring-applied brakes are low-cost and very fast to fit

Posted 11 years ago

Selection guide - universal joints for machinery applications

Posted 11 years ago

Stainless steel quick-locking bushes are easy to clean

Posted 11 years ago

Locking bush prevents damage in the event of machine jams

Posted 11 years ago

Panasonic B-series brushless geared motors and controllers

Posted 11 years ago

Quick-clamping shaft collars need no tools

Posted 11 years ago

ETP Hyloc bush features hydromechanical clamping

Posted 11 years ago

Vogel MPR planetary gearheads gain performance boost

Posted 11 years ago

Hexaflex-Blue marine shaft couplings from Techdrives

Posted 11 years ago

Servomech heavy-duty screw jacks from Techdrives

Posted 11 years ago

Small servo systems offer high performance from 1-phase supply

Posted 11 years ago

Torque limiters and tension/compression limiters

Posted 12 years ago

Pneumatic tooth clutches are compact and versatile

Posted 12 years ago

High-speed electric linear actuators with AC, DC or servo motors

Posted 12 years ago

New options for Patlite LU series signal towers

Posted 12 years ago

Extensive range of electric linear actuators and screw jacks

Posted 12 years ago

New Techdrives website is dedicated to drive components

Posted 12 years ago

Locking bush is quick to release for machine cleaning

Posted 12 years ago

Compact Mönninghoff clutches handle higher torques

Posted 13 years ago

New ranges of sealed stainless steel drive products

Posted 13 years ago

High-visibility, long-life signal towers use LED technology

Posted 13 years ago

Spring-applied brakes guaranteed for 10million operations

Posted 13 years ago

More technical articles