Component compatibility can make or break a good system

Selecting the right components and sub-systems when designing modern machines and technical equipment requires the consideration of many factors; some more obvious than others. Gerard Bush of INMOCO offers some insight into the process.

Engineering designers usually start a project knowing what they want their machine or equipment to achieve; naturally to working backwards from there to get an idea for an initial concept design. It is then a matter of going back and forth, considering different issues and details until a concrete idea is formed. From here the designer may bring in the expertise of a colleague or two, build a prototype - real or virtual - or have a chat with potential end users and develop a strategy for the next stage of the project.

However the project evolves, there will come a point where components have to be selected. The designer may start by thinking: "˜we need a motor', then they will have to consider the technical details of the motor (size, power, speed, dynamic performance, life expectancy, cost, etc). This may lead them towards selection of a particular motor or, perhaps more likely, to a short list of candidate motors.

They may then think: "˜we also need a controller for the motor, plus some sensors for feedback, plus other environmental sensors, plus a gearbox, plus an on/off switch, plus a safety cut-out, plus a housing, etc, etc.'

One issue the designer will need to address is the compatibility of the various components - will they work together well, complementing rather than compromising each other. This can be quite a subtle thing to grasp, but to illustrate it: would you pair a miniature motor with an outsized controller, a precision encoder with a basic sensor, a top of the range gearbox with a cheap-and-cheerful coupling?

Identifying appropriate components requires mental reference to the "˜big picture' - the overall concept of the project. Are you trying to produce a cost-conscious machine, or one that is ultra precise; or one where reliability is king because in-field repairs are going to be almost impossibly difficult; or one with a long working life in a harsh operating environment; or one that may be required to sit dormant for a long time but which can be trusted to "˜fire-up' when finally required to do so?

At this stage many designers will appreciate the help of a specialist, another engineer, one with years of experience and expertise in a particular field, such as motion control. A critically important part of their skill is knowing which products will work well together and which combinations should be avoided. To illustrate this, we can look at some case studies, focussing on embedded, miniature precision motion control.

Spin it to win it

Laboratory centrifuges used in life sciences have to operate at very high rotational speeds. They may also need positioning capabilities so samples align with access covers. They will require a motor, controller, and feedback device, each of which must be compatible with the others and with the duty requirements.

The motor will need to run at say 20,000 rpm; it will also need to be small, quiet, reliable and clean. A brushless DC motor would fulfil these requirements.

An encoder will probably be the best type of feedback device: perhaps surprisingly, a low-cost quadrature encoder may be appropriate. These produce a constant rotational position signal as the motor spins, but can be prone to loss of accuracy at high speed. However, they are suitable for centrifuge applications, if the motor controller is able to produce a real-time indexing signal, which will enable automatic on-the-fly position correction. Thus a relatively low-cost option has been identified that is simple and uses well-proven component technologies so is likely to be reliable.

Two-axis motion

Microscope x"y stages need fast, smooth, and accurate motion, but like centrifuges cost effectiveness is a must. The product will require two independent servo motors, multi"axis point"to-point motion capability and an IC or Printed Circuit Board based controller. One option would be an all"in"one motion board design incorporating say a Magellan motion control IC and the two motors. The axes will need mechanical actuators, probably of the leadscrew or linear motor type.

Significantly, four encoders are also required: a rotary one on each motor, and a linear one on each axis. The rotary encoders are used to stabilise the motion, while the linear one provide position information. This dual loop automatically corrects for mechanical errors from backlash and leadscrew or table assembly non"linearities. The Performance Motion Devices single axis MC58113 supports this dual encoder input and in addition is able to provide very tightly coupled contouring functions when combined with other MC58113 ICs.

Microelectronic wire-bonding

As semiconductors become ever-more compact, wire bonding machines need to become better, faster, smaller more accurate and lower cost. This means the motion control systems must offer constantly improving high-speed positioning, excellent repeatability and high resolution. Naturally, the motion system requirements include very small motors and actuators capable of producing smooth movements and accurate positioning, coupled with a controller that meets the demanding speed and precision requirements of the application.

The motion feedback encoders need to perform in a high electromagnetic interference (EMI) environment with good thermal stability, long cable flex life and high reliability. Miniature encoders such as the Mercury II line from Celera Motion (previously known as MicroE) are cost-effective options for such duties, while the inclusion of a programmable input filter will help to eliminate the effects of high frequency noise in the encoders.

Robots turn for the better

A larger scale industrial application that Celera encoders have been used on is a precision rotary axis control for multiple sequential robot arm joints. Key additional requirements included minimal movement at start-up to report absolute position, and minimal signal cabling to keep the overall arm size as small as possible.

The product chosen involved developing custom-sized PCB-based encoder modules fitted to a rotary disk containing an optical grating. The disk has a reference track in which each index mark is uniquely spaced so that with only a small movement at start-up, multiple index marks can be detected allowing the absolute position to be determined. The system can then be further improved by using two encoders in parallel and comparing the outputs.

Conclusion

It is important that components used in the same system are compatible with one another. Determining the compatibility is not an exact science. It relies on both common sense and experience. Companies, like INMOCO have this expertise and have a product portfolio with a high degree of compatibility between its different ranges. INMOCO engineers are able to think about component compatibility automatically and can fast track your needs towards optimum design options.

Go to www.inmoco.co.uk for more information.

Inmoco

4 Brunel Close
Drayton Fields
Daventry
NN11 8RB
UNITED KINGDOM

+44 (0)1327 307600

info@inmoco.co.uk

www.inmoco.co.uk

More from Inmoco

Miniaturisation in motion control

Posted 5 days ago

New compact actuators deliver high force

Posted 1 month ago

Pumping technologies for precise fluid handling

Posted 3 months ago

High force integrated actuator reduces footprint

Posted 7 months ago

Rod-style electric actuators deliver 222kN thrust

Posted 8 months ago

Smooth motion arc segments, 360-deg rotary direct-drive motors

Posted 9 months ago

Agility Series direct-drive motors feature zero cogging

Posted 10 months ago

Voice coil motors offer precision motion in compact package

Posted 11 months ago

Inductive angle encoders are simple, robust and ultra-precise

Posted 1 year ago

Servo systems cables with improved connectors and labelling

Posted 1 year ago

Low-voltage DC servo motors for high-performance machines

Posted 1 year ago

Inmoco offers alternatives for motors no longer available

Posted 1 year ago

What does the future hold for motion control?

Posted 1 year ago

Simple Co-Engineering options for Kollmorgen AKM 2G servo motors

Posted 1 year ago

New stepper motor controller from Inmoco

Posted 2 years ago

Next-generation servomotors raise machine performance

Posted 2 years ago

Next-generation servo motors deliver 30 per cent more torque

Posted 2 years ago

High-performance actuator range is compact and rugged

Posted 3 years ago

Helicopter actuators may also transfer to other applications

Posted 3 years ago

Miniature encoders help advance surgical robot capabilities

Posted 3 years ago

Compact actuators improve aircraft motion systems

Posted 3 years ago

Encoders step up to help miniaturise electronics

Posted 3 years ago

Linear actuator design enables automated maintenance

Posted 4 years ago

Advanced motion cards provide precise actuation

Posted 4 years ago

Compact DA series actuators deliver quality and reliability

Posted 4 years ago

DA99 linear roller screw actuators increase reliability

Posted 4 years ago

DA Series high-performance electric actuators

Posted 4 years ago

New high-performance actuators available in UK

Posted 4 years ago

Servo motor with Ethernet interface connects directly with CNCs

Posted 4 years ago

Heavy duty linear actuator has high-performance controls

Posted 4 years ago

Single cable, multi-axis servo systems gets more power

Posted 5 years ago

Precision motion chips for dedicated controllers

Posted 5 years ago

Hygienic motor range has new feedback and connector options

Posted 5 years ago

Inmoco launches KOLLMORGEN safety feedback option

Posted 5 years ago

MC58113 Series programmable motion control chips

Posted 5 years ago

MicroE Veratus Series encoders: smart and reliable

Posted 5 years ago

Smaller, smarter encoders from Inmoco

Posted 5 years ago

Servo controller doubles power

Posted 5 years ago

Maintenance-free linear motors delivery high power density

Posted 5 years ago

PCB-based options are mighty minis for motor control

Posted 5 years ago

Vacuum-rated encoders from Inmoco

Posted 6 years ago

Minutes to motion - linear positioning explained

Posted 6 years ago

Servo users should not be seduced by power density alone

Posted 6 years ago

Inmoco introduces hygienic motor-gear combination

Posted 6 years ago

Servo technology is moving to a new paradigm

Posted 6 years ago

Compact washdown motor offers excellent performance

Posted 6 years ago

Maintenance-free lifting columns are easy to fit

Posted 6 years ago

Electric actuator optimises machine design and saves energy

Posted 6 years ago

Encoder offers value and performance plus flexible mounting

Posted 6 years ago

User-friendly compact encoder gets new side mount option

Posted 6 years ago

Reduce cabling with distributed servo drives from Inmoco

Posted 6 years ago

New functions make servo super-safe

Posted 7 years ago

Power storage modules act as servo UPS

Posted 7 years ago

Inmoco expands indexer family with motion features

Posted 7 years ago

Motion card integrates amps with full motion control

Posted 7 years ago

Wizard aids easy set-up of embedded motion controllers

Posted 7 years ago

EtherCAT master module for CTC 5300 Blue Fusion controller

Posted 7 years ago

OPC server gives instant access to automation controllers

Posted 7 years ago

Atlas single-axis motion amplifier is multi-talented

Posted 7 years ago

Rotary encoder establishes absolute position at start-up

Posted 7 years ago

Inmoco goes back to BASIC with new programmable servodrive

Posted 7 years ago

Mid-performance, high torque per pound servomotor

Posted 7 years ago

Stepper motors: advanced techniques

Posted 8 years ago

How to calculate point-to-point SCARA movements

Posted 8 years ago

Trombone servo drive range now has increased power

Posted 8 years ago

M4-X DC servomotor range is rugged and high performance

Posted 8 years ago

Achieve smaller, faster, smarter motion control

Posted 8 years ago

Expandable motion control system for extreme conditions

Posted 8 years ago

Elmo Gold Drum HV extends servo drive range to 65kW

Posted 8 years ago

B-Hornet military servo for high-power burst applications

Posted 8 years ago

O.P.S. Optical Encoders can be customised

Posted 8 years ago

ORMEC XD indexer family of servo drives expanded

Posted 8 years ago

Free automation systems control app for iPhone and iPad

Posted 8 years ago

Inmoco's Elmo Gold Servo Drives gain EtherCAT compliance

Posted 8 years ago

Inmoco introduces Elmo's DC Trombone digital servo drive

Posted 8 years ago

Robust linear actuators with integral force measurement

Posted 9 years ago

Energy-efficient IP67 stainless steel servo motors

Posted 11 years ago

Servo drives can be networked with IEEE 1394b

Posted 11 years ago

Wider choice of combined motion control and PLC units

Posted 11 years ago

Electronic cam controller suits labelling and capping machines

Posted 11 years ago

High-resolution encoder offers exceptional versatility

Posted 11 years ago

Elmo Duo controller integrates twin Whistle servo drives

Posted 11 years ago

Compact Guitar servo drive delivers 5kW of power

Posted 11 years ago

Ethernet/IP and Modbus options for multi-axis network manager

Posted 12 years ago

Elmo Solo Whistle saves servo application design time

Posted 12 years ago

New three-axis stepper modules for programmable controller

Posted 12 years ago

Electric linear actuators incorporate force measurement

Posted 12 years ago

Miniature ChipEncoder measures just 7x11mm

Posted 13 years ago

Cost-effective alternative for linear positioning and control

Posted 13 years ago

Rotary actuator includes servo motor, amp and position control

Posted 13 years ago

CANopen and absolute encoder options for digital servo drives

Posted 13 years ago

Programmable encoders feature miniature sensors

Posted 13 years ago

MicroE Systems' Mercury II digital encoder 'sets new benchmark'

Posted 13 years ago

Inmoco introduces ServoWire Motion and Logic Controller

Posted 13 years ago

Inmoco now offers Servotecnica slip rings

Posted 14 years ago

Inmoco launches "world's smallest" 50-nanometre encoder

Posted 14 years ago

High-resolution encoder is claimed to be the world's fastest

Posted 14 years ago

More technical articles
10 hours ago
New bifold constant torque hinge improves user experience
Southco has expanded its popular range of position control hinges with a new version that has been specifically designed for fold-out tables in passenger transit interior applications
11 hours ago
New FDA compliant cable entry plates
Foremost Electronics has introduced new KEL-DPZ-HD FDA compliant cable entry plates from icotek, specially developed for the use in the food and pharmaceutical industries
4 days ago
Boxing clever
A new chainflex cable box means big shipping cost savings for customers
4 days ago
New industrial vision online channel sees the light of day
Industrial vision provider IDS is making its expertise as a manufacturer of digital industrial cameras available free of charge and readily accessible on a new platform
4 days ago
Ball screws help protect buildings from earthquakes
Ball screws from NSK are helping to protect structures and people in earthquake zones
4 days ago
ATEX certification for new pneumatic valve island
Pneumatic process control offers numerous benefits, especially in hygienic applications. Bürkert says that its new Type 8652 AirLINE valve island provides users with improved safety features, communications and diagnostics
4 days ago
ABB launches condition-based maintenance service for robots
New service enables users to plan ahead and optimise production performance
4 days ago
What the UK-EU trade deal means for UK vehicle manufacturers
Now the UK has left the EU, the transition period has ended and the two parties have established a new trading relationship, UK-based vehicle manufacturers have some clarity over what they need to do to serve three key markets: Great Britain (England, Scotland and Wales), the EU and Northern Ireland
4 days ago
Farnell publishes Industry 4.0 ebook
New ‘Industry 4.0 Interviews’ ebook is available for free download from Farnell and showcases the opinions of leading global experts on the future of IIoT and Industry 4.0
4 days ago
Can DC motors be used at high temperatures?
There is no need for a heated discussion about it as maxon’s motor expert Andrew Gibson offers a view on the subject