Control signals - which option is best?

As process control systems continue to advance and the use of complicated networked systems develops, is there still a requirement for the simple analogue signal? Chris Hoey of Bürkert provides an insight into selecting the correct control signals to produce the optimum process control system.

It is about 20 years since the industry "˜experts' stated that 4-20mA would disappear from the market, to be replaced by digital networks or fieldbus systems. While there is some truth that networked systems have taken a large portion of market share, 4-20mA is still alive and kicking. There are two main reasons for this: first, higher-priced intelligent sensors, made for specific networks are not always the most cost-effective options, nor are the "˜smart' features on offer from intelligent field devices always wanted or required.

Second, the process control industry has changed significantly, with much more automation being installed into smaller plants, like food processing, water treatment, remote monitoring, etc. It could be said that 4-20mA was the last truly universal signal, accepted by every system, every vendor, and every control component. This means that single control loops, small plants and transportable skid-type equipment will always have a need for the simple, low-cost option that 4-20mA offers.

Let's not forget just how versatile this "˜simple' signal is. It uses just two wires to transmit the signal, it can power the field transmitter with its own supply voltage and it can run for long distances on standard cable. Using the live zero (4mA instead of 0mA) it senses a cable break or instrument failure, it is not overly susceptible to noise, it is highly accurate and low-cost. The downside is that two wires can only carry one variable or instrument.

However, as the number of control loops increases, the costs start to multiply, as you need individual cables, glands, terminals and inputs for every element. As well as the hardware, the space it requires and, most importantly, labour to design, install and commission, make it uncompetitive versus fieldbus networks in applications with many sensors and feedback devices. It is different for every installation, but there is a point where the change from an analogue to a digital network becomes more cost effective.

By using fieldbus networks, you can now have thousands of inputs and outputs on a single cable. This reduces the infrastructure that you would have needed for a traditional system and can save up to 50 per cent of project costs, even though the actual hardware becomes more expensive. By using smart field equipment, the entire transmission of the signal is digitally accurate and generally there is configuration and often diagnostic data available. This methodology is suitable for large plant design, especially for heavy industry like petrochemical.

The hybrid system

The downside is the number of choices that a process designer has to make when designing these systems, the first being which network, as you cannot easily mix networks on site. While the most popular networks used are not proprietary, they are still not available from all vendors, which starts to limit choices in components, even though they may be better suited to the application. For these reasons, it is rare to see a site that utilises only digital networks; however, almost every larger site does use fieldbus technology. This leads us to the most common installation, the hybrid system.

A hybrid system incorporates both technologies. The 4-20mA is used in the field, which keeps the components generic and lower cost, and then the signal is fed into a field Input/Output (I/O) panel where these signals are clustered and then transmitted to the central control via fieldbus. Without doubt, this system is the lowest cost to implement and is simple to understand and maintain. The only downside for a network that is not fully digital is that you most likely won't get configuration or diagnostic information from the field instrument, but the upside is that the instrument itself will be considerably lower cost. In order to clearly show where each communication option may fit, let's look at an example.

Imagine a single flow control loop; say it is the water feed to another process that needs to be maintained at the same rate. We would choose a flow meter based on the application requirements, with 4-20mA output. To control the flow, we would choose a modulating control valve with 4-20mA input. But to close the loop, we need a Proportional Integral Derivative (PID) controller between these two instruments that can be configured to the application; this will need a 4-20mA input and output - done.

Now let's say there are 15 of these loops, all identical, and the plant manager wants to monitor and record the flows in the system (assume a PLC & SCADA layer). Using 4-20mA, we would now need to send 15 signals to the PLC, plus 15 signals out, needing 6-8 input cards and as many as 90 terminals, 30 glands, cable tray, panel space, power supplies, signal isolation, etc. Now this option starts to become more expensive.

The digital option

Let's try fully digital. We will choose a fieldbus protocol, such as Profibus. We will need to install a Profibus master at the PLC (unless it is incorporated) and then choose a flow meter that has Profibus, as well as a control valve that has Profibus. So now we have one slot in the PLC rack, one gland and one cable to all the devices. The PLC can now read the process signal and control the loop as well as log the data, via the 30 fieldbus nodes.

The only downside is that the field equipment is now more expensive, sometimes considerably, and specific to Profibus, so if the plant changed to Ethernet in 2 years, the field equipment would have to be discarded or a customised network-network gateway would need to be installed. This design is far more complex and may require highly qualified maintenance engineers.

A hybrid option would be to use the original lower-cost field equipment, but to wire them directly to a local (field) I/O panel that converts them to Profibus and transmits them to the PLC. You get the cost savings of the installation, with lower cost field instrumentation, even allowing for the I/O cluster hardware. For this example the hybrid design provides the most cost-effective option.

Bürkert has systems available for each of the options above. The customer can choose the installation that suits them. But, what if this customer came to Bürkert with this application at the design stage? The company would choose flow meters with 4-20mA output (8035) and feed these directly into the modulating valves (2301) with Profibus-enabled positioner and optional inbuilt PID controller (8693). This device would control the flows directly as well as transmit process, output, configuration and even diagnostic data to the PLC, via just 15 fieldbus nodes. This "˜Bürkert' system, although being partly hybrid, would give all the functionality of the fully digital system, yet be around 30 per cent lower cost than the cheapest option above.

There is no perfect fit for all situations. There are many considerations that weigh into the correct selection of the site signal wiring, with cost being just one. Always seek competent advice and develop a tool that will estimate the total cost of the installation, including hardware, software and labour. Then consider whether it will be easy to commission and maintain, and whether you have the competence on site for fieldbus technology. As explained above, Bürkert has systems for all options, so have no bias towards one or the other, just a commitment to delivering value and long-term reliability.

To learn more about control signal systems from Bürkert, please visit www.burkert.co.uk.

Burkert Fluid Control Systems

Fluid Control Centre
1 Bridge End
Cirencester
GL7 1QY
UNITED KINGDOM

+44 (0)1285 648720

sales.uk@burkert.com

www.burkert.co.uk

More from Burkert Fluid Control Systems

Unifying the process control network

Posted 1 week ago

Bürkert valves ensure latest standards prevail

Posted 4 weeks ago

Sweet success for process control reliability

Posted 1 month ago

Full steam ahead for training

Posted 1 month ago

Process valve island increases dosing accuracy

Posted 2 months ago

Carbon capture technology on the rise

Posted 3 months ago

Water treatment improvements for power station hit full flow

Posted 3 months ago

Network integration – search for value and simplicity

Posted 4 months ago

ATEX certification for new pneumatic valve island

Posted 4 months ago

Ironing out the doubt: iron measurement in water quality analysis

Posted 5 months ago

Flowmeter range expands

Posted 6 months ago

Pure water: quality monitoring is a vital asset

Posted 6 months ago

New flow controller for low volumes

Posted 7 months ago

Delivering high precision for time-pressure microlitre dosing

Posted 8 months ago

Monitoring reverse osmosis systems

Posted 1 year ago

Online water analysis module continuously measures iron content

Posted 1 year ago

Movie of the month

Posted 1 year ago

Time-pressure controller for high-precision microlitre dosing

Posted 1 year ago

How to simplify industrial process automation using IO-Link

Posted 1 year ago

Multi-parameter flow meter cuts waste by identifying fluids

Posted 1 year ago

Burkert invests in fully automated multi-medium testing facility

Posted 1 year ago

Burkert UK now supplying customisable micro precision pumps

Posted 1 year ago

Bürkert appoints new Account Manager for the South West

Posted 1 year ago

Smart valve positioner features IO-Link connectivity

Posted 1 year ago

Bürkert delivers savings for new life science facility

Posted 1 year ago

How to choose the right process control valves

Posted 1 year ago

Controller achieves micro-precision for time-pressure dosing

Posted 1 year ago

Intelligent valve islands for process automation applications

Posted 1 year ago

Retrofitted control heads extend life of 200 process valves

Posted 1 year ago

Enhanced radar level measurement for hygienic applications

Posted 1 year ago

Bürkert microfluidics expertise improves antibody discovery

Posted 1 year ago

Bürkert launches compact Type 6164 cartridge valve

Posted 1 year ago

Continuous monitoring and analysis of water quality

Posted 1 year ago

What is needed to improve fuel cell technology?

Posted 1 year ago

Flow measurement in the food and beverage sector

Posted 1 year ago

Bürkert virtual exhibition stand offers web and VR experience

Posted 1 year ago

Integrated water quality monitoring for water treatment service

Posted 2 years ago

Movie of the month

Posted 2 years ago

Flexible water analysis system saves time and money

Posted 2 years ago

Bürkert UK expands stock of standard process valves

Posted 2 years ago

Hygienic flowmeter specified for pharmaceutical cleaning system

Posted 2 years ago

Process control expertise at the ISPE Europe Annual Conference

Posted 2 years ago

Flowmeter gains the ability to detect different fluids

Posted 2 years ago

Finding the right partner for hygienic process control projects

Posted 2 years ago

Burkert UK expands product range and increases stockholding

Posted 2 years ago

Brewery upgrade improves reliability

Posted 2 years ago

multiCELL controller supports Champagne production

Posted 2 years ago

Support for system integrators

Posted 2 years ago

Burkert contributes to more efficient fluid control system

Posted 2 years ago

Burkert to exhibit hygienic products at EHEDG Conference 2018

Posted 2 years ago

Patties still a firm favourite thanks to 10-year-lasting valves

Posted 2 years ago

Multifunction controller features Ethernet connectivity

Posted 2 years ago

Solenoid control in potentially explosive atmospheres

Posted 2 years ago

New monitoring system simplifies micro-filtration of water

Posted 2 years ago

Micro-dosing technology and process integration

Posted 2 years ago

Using automation to improve process water quality

Posted 2 years ago

Movie of the month

Posted 3 years ago

Optimising repeatability and efficiency through automation

Posted 3 years ago

New flowmeters to look out for in 2018

Posted 3 years ago

Simplified process control for reverse osmosis plant

Posted 3 years ago

Comparing flowmeters: Coriolis vs. Surface Acoustic Wave

Posted 3 years ago

Precision control for CIP processes

Posted 3 years ago

Pneumatic valve island improves flexibility and diagnostics

Posted 3 years ago

Bürkert's new valve control heads provide networking options

Posted 3 years ago

Using Industry 4.0 to optimise process control

Posted 3 years ago

Re-engineering diaphragm valves

Posted 3 years ago

Taking pneumatic process control to a new level

Posted 3 years ago

Precise flow control for efficient, accurate pneumatic conveying

Posted 3 years ago

High-temperature control for exhaust analysis

Posted 3 years ago

Burkert: managing a culture of innovation

Posted 3 years ago

More function modules for Burkert compact water analysis system

Posted 3 years ago

Bürkert Pneumatic Control Valve Island interfaces with ET 200SP

Posted 3 years ago

Wave of success for new flowmeters"¦

Posted 3 years ago

Bürkert UK extends customisation and assembly service

Posted 3 years ago

Optimum level and flow control for food industry processes

Posted 3 years ago

Minimising waste in hygienic control valve applications

Posted 3 years ago

Seal of approval for Bürkert solenoid valves

Posted 4 years ago

How to choose a surface coating technology

Posted 4 years ago

Bürkert increases stock levels to support maintenance market

Posted 4 years ago

Do Food & Beverage SMEs need more process automation?

Posted 4 years ago

New light-weight precision flow meter suits process skids

Posted 4 years ago

Developing an alternative to Coriolis

Posted 4 years ago

Improving flow control in pneumatic conveying systems

Posted 4 years ago

Delivering on the requirement for ATEX control panels

Posted 4 years ago

Bürkert maintains price freeze for 2017

Posted 4 years ago

Bürkert offers fast delivery on full-bore mag flowmeters

Posted 4 years ago

Bürkert appoints new account manager for Ireland

Posted 4 years ago

Steam control valves: getting the most from this vital component

Posted 4 years ago

New networkable hygienic valve actuators from Bürkert

Posted 4 years ago

Pneumatic valves for SIL1 or SIL2 safety control systems

Posted 4 years ago

Bespoke process control systems for the food & beverage industry

Posted 4 years ago

Electromotive process valves deliver precision alternative

Posted 4 years ago

Clinical diagnosis benefits from design collaboration

Posted 4 years ago

Keeping control valves clean, inside and out

Posted 4 years ago

Hygienic 2-way bellows control valve for small flow rates

Posted 4 years ago

Upgrading process safety with compact control valves

Posted 4 years ago

Top 10 level-sensing technologies

Posted 4 years ago

Fast, reliable switching without pneumatics

Posted 4 years ago

Retrofit safety using innovative control valves

Posted 4 years ago

Bürkert launches Virtual Water Treatment Works

Posted 4 years ago

Building selective catalytic reduction systems

Posted 5 years ago

Emerging food preservation technology requires precision control

Posted 5 years ago

Precision gas control for experimental combustion rig

Posted 5 years ago

Electromotive process valves make compressed air obsolete

Posted 5 years ago

Meeting the demand for more complex process control systems

Posted 5 years ago

Bürkert cartridge valve is suitable for custom manifold designs

Posted 5 years ago

Developing new fluid management systems for in-vitro diagnostics

Posted 5 years ago

Bürkert launches hydroformed hygienic diaphragm valve

Posted 5 years ago

Bürkert improves functionality of ELEMENT controllers

Posted 5 years ago

Gas control for metal surface treatments

Posted 5 years ago

Measuring pH in a food-safe environment

Posted 5 years ago

Process control design - don't let ATEX restrict your plans

Posted 5 years ago

Bürkert application segmentation delivers across industries

Posted 5 years ago

Desktop autoclaves achieve reliability with Bürkert steam valves

Posted 5 years ago

Designs for controlling hot processes - it's all material

Posted 5 years ago

Controlling CIP / SIP in food processing applications

Posted 5 years ago

Energy saving with process valves

Posted 5 years ago

Solenoid valves - one for every occasion

Posted 5 years ago

Bürkert valve expertise delivers a premium shower experience

Posted 5 years ago

Control of water treatment with Bürkert multiCELL

Posted 5 years ago

Solenoid valves - some are more equal than others

Posted 5 years ago

Design & maintenance crucial to avoiding water hammer

Posted 5 years ago

Bürkert hazardous area-rated pneumatics in whisky bottling plant

Posted 6 years ago

Under Pressure - sensors in the spotlight

Posted 6 years ago

All new Bürkert website: cool tools, easy navigation and eShop

Posted 6 years ago

Bürkert helps to improve efficiency at UK car engine plant

Posted 6 years ago

Autoclave uses compact Bürkert process valves to meet targets

Posted 6 years ago

Free solenoid valve selection chart offered by Bürkert

Posted 6 years ago

Solenoid valves - an enduring design refined over time

Posted 6 years ago

Intelligent control for food processors

Posted 6 years ago

Bürkert's fluid control expertise now available direct to OEMs

Posted 6 years ago

Bürkert's multiCELL provides localised sensor signal management

Posted 6 years ago

Water control and analysis system with plug-in Sensor Cubes

Posted 6 years ago

Making the grade - achieving compliance with food standards

Posted 6 years ago

Bürkert releases new flowmeters for high-volume gases

Posted 6 years ago

Sensors 101: understanding sensors within a fluid control system

Posted 6 years ago

Modular valve body reduces energy needs and improves system flow

Posted 6 years ago

Sizing of pipework for steam applications for reliable operation

Posted 6 years ago

New valve body concept simplifies complex pipe interfaces

Posted 7 years ago

Design and components for pneumatic control automation systems

Posted 7 years ago

Improved functionality for batch controller and flow transmitter

Posted 7 years ago

Efficient bespoke effluent monitoring and batch control systems

Posted 7 years ago

Intelligent valve reduces pipework by switching multiple flows

Posted 7 years ago

Steam expertise reduces costs in pet food production

Posted 7 years ago

Bürkert Technical Training to provide local options for 2014

Posted 7 years ago

Local development process delivers micro-fluidic valve systems

Posted 7 years ago

Electrically actuated quarter-turn valves for a range of options

Posted 7 years ago

Steam: how to manage it safely & efficiently

Posted 7 years ago

Free guide matches valves with chemical resistance properties

Posted 7 years ago

Fruit syrup production benefits from smart valve control

Posted 7 years ago

Tried and tested valve design nears 50 years of reliable service

Posted 7 years ago

Does your valve have the correct chemical resistance properties?

Posted 7 years ago

Microfluidics - micro dosing pump is precise and reliable

Posted 7 years ago

Integrated modular systems are key to precise gas handling

Posted 7 years ago

Bürkert improves control of water oxygenation

Posted 7 years ago

What's next in process control for the water treatment industry?

Posted 7 years ago

Retrofit control head enables automation of most process valves

Posted 7 years ago

Bürkert unveils new intelligent valve positioner

Posted 7 years ago

Bürkert reports excellent results from Total expo

Posted 7 years ago

Valves - when to repair or replace?

Posted 7 years ago

Bürkert launches new range of intelligent valve control heads

Posted 8 years ago

Seminar on valve innovation in the pharmaceutical sector

Posted 8 years ago

Free ATEX selection poster demystifies explosion criteria

Posted 8 years ago

Bürkert at Total Process & Packaging Exhibition 2013

Posted 8 years ago

New training brochure now available from Bürkert

Posted 8 years ago

Bürkert valves help TV science show with 360 degree swing

Posted 8 years ago

Direct-acting solenoid valves for fluids, gases, vacuum & steam

Posted 8 years ago

Free booklet for products and systems for producing clean steam

Posted 8 years ago

AS-I communication bus-equipped Element diaphragm valves

Posted 8 years ago

Bürkert UK officially opens the doors to its new UK headquarters

Posted 8 years ago

Fuel-cell race car relies on Bürkert valve technology

Posted 8 years ago

Bürkert Technical Training Schedule released for 2013

Posted 8 years ago

Burkert launches new butterfly valves

Posted 8 years ago

Burkert UK moves to new UK headquarters in Cirencester

Posted 8 years ago

Process valves that can "˜think' for themselves

Posted 8 years ago

AirLINE Quick valve island pneumatic system for process controls

Posted 8 years ago

Modern alternative to conventional variable area flow meters

Posted 8 years ago

Free Steam Site Guide aims to make steam systems safer

Posted 8 years ago

Design & Manufacture service for packaged batch controls

Posted 8 years ago

New multiCELL universal transmitter and sensor controller

Posted 8 years ago

Miniature valves for medical equipment reduce energy consumption

Posted 8 years ago

Three-tier approach for automation of hygienic processes

Posted 8 years ago

Free Select Catalogue provides faster fluid control deliveries

Posted 8 years ago

Multi-port valve interfaces meet life science plant requirements

Posted 8 years ago

Universal control head for hygienic processing industries

Posted 9 years ago

Flow transmitter and pulse divider combined in a single device

Posted 9 years ago

Express delivery for Namur interface valves from Burkert

Posted 9 years ago

Problem of contaminant ingress into diaphragm valves solved

Posted 9 years ago

Process automation quadruples brewery production

Posted 9 years ago

AirLINE Quick simplifies assembly of pneumatic control panels

Posted 9 years ago

Free training courses in Hygienic Processing

Posted 9 years ago

See Element process control products at Sensors + Systems

Posted 9 years ago

Digital flow transmitters are designed to be future-proof

Posted 9 years ago

Fountain control saves space, energy and money

Posted 9 years ago

Burkert extends Element range of process control components

Posted 9 years ago

Automated CIP saves pharmaceutical manufacturer £120,000 pa

Posted 9 years ago

PFA-lined stainless steel diaphragm valves resist corrosion

Posted 9 years ago

Type 2080 2/2-way valve with PTFE bellows for hygienic processes

Posted 9 years ago

Drinks manufacturer installs intelligent process valves

Posted 9 years ago

Multi-functional valve block for steam sterilisation systems

Posted 9 years ago

8175 ultrasonic level transmitter in IP65 or IP67 housings

Posted 10 years ago

Free courses: steam engineering and condensate management

Posted 10 years ago

Single controller for both process and proportional valves

Posted 10 years ago

Miniature solenoid valves specified for dosing machine

Posted 10 years ago

Element Neutrino analytical transmitters are more versatile

Posted 10 years ago

SideControl units achieve intelligent valve positioning

Posted 10 years ago

Customised ball valves used in fuel tank protection system

Posted 10 years ago

Burkert registers on Achilles Utilities Vendor Database

Posted 10 years ago

Ex-proof AirLINE Ex 8650 system chosen for North Sea project

Posted 10 years ago

Enamel-coated pH sensors offer advantages over glass types

Posted 10 years ago

Online monitoring of the reverse-osmosis systems

Posted 10 years ago

Control system replaces manual manufacturing process

Posted 10 years ago

Burkert appoints Fluid Controls as SE England distributor

Posted 10 years ago

How to save energy in hazardous area control systems

Posted 10 years ago

Miniature 3/2 isolation valve 'sets new benchmark'

Posted 11 years ago

Integrated liquid flow controller incorporates valve and sensor

Posted 11 years ago

Positioners/process controllers can mount on valve actuators

Posted 11 years ago

Spot welder 'tip off' detection using intelligent cooling system

Posted 11 years ago

Clever design halves the number of valves required

Posted 11 years ago

Compact flipper isolation valve delivers improved performance

Posted 11 years ago

Featured photo

Posted 11 years ago

Engine test rig benefits from globe valves and positioners

Posted 11 years ago

Valve and positioner provide test rig coolant control

Posted 11 years ago

Robolux valves eliminate deadlegs and save costs

Posted 11 years ago

Microfluidics offer benefits for automation and miniaturisation

Posted 11 years ago

Burkert and BBS-Systems partner for hygienic processing

Posted 11 years ago

New version of mxControl multi-parameter controller

Posted 11 years ago

New fluid control systems catalogue from Burkert

Posted 11 years ago

Bio-diesel processor developed with help from Burkert

Posted 11 years ago

Electrical and pneumatic systems in hazardous areas

Posted 11 years ago

Ultrasonic flow transmitter delivers long-term stability

Posted 11 years ago

Posted 12 years ago

Free Brewery Process Control brochure from Burkert

Posted 12 years ago

Burkert launches Element modular process control products

Posted 12 years ago

MicroFluidics catalogue of standard and bespoke systems

Posted 12 years ago

Pick-and-mix modular general-purpose solenoid valves

Posted 13 years ago

446-page catalogue covers all fluid control needs

Posted 13 years ago

More technical articles