Innovations in moving-coil actuator technology

In this second technical note on moving-coil actuators, Ed Neff, President of SMAC Moving Coil Actuators (MCA), describes how moving-coil technology is evolving rapidly and offering a competitive alternative to pneumatic drives and moving-magnet rotary motors.

Moving-coil technology has been around for a long time and works in both rotary and linear motors. In brush-type rotary servo motors based on moving-coil technology, the brush provides the means for current to reach the coil. In contrast, single-pole linear motors - often called voice coils - are at the heart of many speakers.

The introduction of high-strength neodymium magnets has greatly expanded the applicability of moving-coil actuators in motion applications, as actuators with these magnets output high force (or torque).

The light moving mass of their coils makes the actuators excel in many industrial applications because it allows for high cycle rates up to twice that of pneumatic or ball screw actuators. In addition, moving-coil actuators have:

  • Long cycle life - up to 10 times that of pneumatic or ball screw linear actuators
  • High repeatability over each cycle - to 10 per cent the variance found in pneumatic devices
  • Programmable force and torque output
  • The ability to provide movement for very slow speed applications.

Two factors restrict the technology's wider implementation.

1. Cost: Moving-coil linear motors (and their accompanying motion controllers) have until recently cost five times more than pneumatic cylinders and valves of comparable size, and triple that of stepper-motor-based ball screw actuators.

2. Current input: Moving-coil actuators require a mode to get current to the coil - via brushes for rotary actuators and flex cables for linear variations. The former wears out and the latter is limited to strokes of about 500mm or shorter.

Cost reductions

Even so, this is changing, with moving-coil actuators seeing an uptick in use for several reasons relating to simplicity and cost effectiveness:

1. Encoder cost has dropped to below $15; this is mostly due to the development of low-cost chips by a number of makers and the development of low-cost plastic scales.

2. The cost (and size) of motion controllers and amplifiers have also dropped significantly. Volume pricing is now approaching $100 per axis and will continue to decrease. This is due in part to the increased use of servo motors in automotive applications.

Image
3. Coil manufacturing cost is rapidly dropping. This is due to the advent of new printed-coil technology and all the substantial benefits it imparts:

  • No soldering
  • Resistance variation to 1 per cent of that of wound coils
  • Very low-cost tool-up of new designs - with a typical expenditure of about $5000
  • Ability to print coil shapes that are impossible to wind
  • Ability to integrate the flex cable, encoder and main connector into a printed flex circuit (thereby reducing part count and assembly cost)

4. Magnet manufacture. Another factor shrinking the price of certain moving-coil actuators is the way in which some manufacturers reduce the cost of the magnets by cutting long magnets to size and magnetizing them in-house.

5. Certain manufacturers can also replace linear guides with flexures for short strokes of less than 30mm to leverage the fact that flexures can cost less than $1.

Today, moving-coil servo actuators with built-in controller amplifiers are priced at around $350 (for volume orders) and are therefore comparable in price to actuators that incorporate ball screws - though they are still two to three times the cost of pneumatic systems. That said, prices are projected to drop another 35 per cent as the factors listed above begin to affect the market.

The other factor restricting the technology's wider implementation is its need for a brush or flex cable. Here a solution could be on the horizon. University of Eindhoven researchers have demonstrated wireless power transmission on moving coil rotating servo motors. It is technically feasible to apply this not only to rotary moving-coil motors but to linear actuators as well. The main hurdles here are cost and the size of the power-transmitting components. But advances continue, so expect this technology to appear on the market in the near future.

Learn more at www.smac-mca.co.uk.

The first Technical Note in the series from SMAC can be read here: What is a moving coil actuator?.

SMAC Moving Coil Actuators

Ikon House
Rutherford Way
Crawley
RH10 9PB
UNITED KINGDOM

+44 (0)1293 520147

info@smac-mca.com

www.smac-mca.co.uk

More from SMAC Moving Coil Actuators

What is a moving coil actuator?

Posted 1 year ago

Stackable linear actuators are fast and cost-competitive

Posted 1 year ago

SMAC wins business manufacturing high capacity EV batteries

Posted 2 years ago

SMAC introduces GUI for thread checking and other apps

Posted 2 years ago

SMAC electric actuator doubles pneumatic actuator eject speed

Posted 3 years ago

Smart Screwdrivers combine control and monitoring functions

Posted 3 years ago

SMAC Moving Coil Actuators introduces Tech Niches

Posted 3 years ago

Programmable micro gripper for handling small, fragile parts

Posted 3 years ago

SMAC introduces 'world's thinnest moving coil linear motor'

Posted 3 years ago

CBL50: expansion of the CBL series electric cylinder from SMAC

Posted 5 years ago

CBL35C series electric cylinder with built-in controller

Posted 6 years ago

SLA25: precision linear slide with cross-roller guide

Posted 6 years ago

SMAC introduces high-performance CBL Series electric cylinders

Posted 6 years ago

Cost-effective electric cylinder delivers high performance

Posted 11 years ago

Posted 11 years ago

New SMAC website for moving-coil actuators

Posted 11 years ago

Miniature electric actuators feature integral feedback

Posted 12 years ago

Compact gripper for handling and measuring applications

Posted 12 years ago

Fully automated system checks screw threads

Posted 12 years ago

Moving coil actuator sorts parts at ultra-high speeds

Posted 13 years ago

Moving coil actuators selected for switch test applications

Posted 13 years ago

Electric actuators are direct replacements for pneumatics

Posted 13 years ago

Actuator delivers benefits of electronics and pneumatics

Posted 13 years ago

High-speed gripper incorporates high-precision measurement

Posted 13 years ago

SMAC develops ultra-high-speed pick-and-place

Posted 13 years ago

More technical articles
2 days ago
Automatic bearing lubrication brings ore inspiring results in mining
By installing automatic lubricators for bearings on its conveyor drive motors and belt pulleys, an opencast mine in Hungary has seen a range of benefits, including the prevention of unplanned downtime, longer bearing life and reduced repair work
2 days ago
Kinoulton company conveys COVID-combating masks
Here's a great example of the germ of an idea resulting in the combating of COVID
2 days ago
FLIR Systems announces four new Exx-Series handheld thermal imaging cameras
New E96, E86, E76 and E54 models feature enhanced thermal resolution and provide on-camera routing capability for more efficient inspections
3 days ago
New C-Mount lenses bring focus for machine and system builders
IDS now offers more than 20 new C-mount lenses with resolutions of 5, 8 and 10 MP as well as different focal lengths and optical classes
3 days ago
Backup DC motor for two rolling mill applications
Menzel Elektromotoren has built a replica of an old DC motor for a large German steel strip manufacturer
3 days ago
Distributed safety systems webinar 30th October 0930
In this webinar Pilz UK Product Manager David Collier will examine the state-of-the-art technology available to meet the demands of decentralisation
3 days ago
New narrow FeedThrough connectors save panel space
New from Cliff Electronics is the SLIMS FeedThrough Connector range, designed and manufactured in the UK
4 days ago
New autoglide 5 system from igus doesn’t need a guide trough
A new energy chain system for intralogistics and crane systems has been designed by motion plastics experts igus
4 days ago
New DC/AC converter unveiled by Phoenix Contact
With the arrival of its new DC/AC inverter (part of the Phoenix Contact Quint Power family) the company says that machine builders now have a compact solution to generate alternating current in DC applications
4 days ago
New-generation bullet train runs on NSK bearings
High-performance bearings from NSK are now operational in the newly developed N700S Shinkansen (bullet train)