Safe maintenance and the influence of machine guard design

Jeremy Procter, a Member of BSI's MCE/3 committee (Safeguarding of Machinery), former Convenor of the European Standards Committee responsible for Machine Guards (CEN TC114 WG11), and Managing Director of Procter Machine Guarding, explains the role that machine guarding plays in improving safety during maintenance operations.

When you look at the statistics, it is easy to see why the European Agency for Safety and Health at Work (EU-OSHA) is co-ordinating the European Healthy Workplaces Campaign on Safe Maintenance 2010-2011, the UK part of which was launched in June 2010 by the HSE (Health and Safety Executive) in conjunction with organisations representing employers, workers and other interested bodies - including the Trades Union Congress (TUC) and EEF, The Manufacturers' Organisation. The HSE's analysis of data from recent years indicates that 25-30 per cent of manufacturing industry fatalities in Great Britain were related to maintenance activities.

In this context, maintenance activities include inspection, testing, measurement, replacement, adjustment, repair, upkeep, fault detection (troubleshooting), servicing, lubrication and cleaning. It should also be borne in mind that maintenance activities fall within two categories: proactive (preventative) and reactive (corrective). Most accidents occur during corrective maintenance, and note that the need for corrective maintenance can be due to a lack of preventative maintenance. In some cases inadequate preventative maintenance can contribute towards catastrophic failures, injuries and even fatalities. Leaving aside these extreme situations, the unexpected nature of reactive maintenance tends to result in these activities being less well planned, and they might also involve work that was not foreseen by the original machine manufacturer, hence the machine maintenance manual lacks specific instructions.

Risk assessment

It might be assumed that guards always need to be removed for maintenance, so their design has little bearing on the safety of maintenance operations. However, this assumption is incorrect and the design of the guarding can make a significant difference. Machine designers should therefore give due consideration to the outcome of the initial risk assessment (which needs to cover maintenance as well as normal operation) and, ideally, they should discuss maintenance operations with personnel from all shifts, as it is not unknown for maintenance operations to be undertaken differently during night shifts or weekends than during office hours due to fewer managers being present at these times.

When designing machine guards (and, if necessary, other aspects of the machinery) it is best to provide means by which maintenance operations can be performed without having to open or remove the guards. For example, external grease points can be installed, viewing panels can be incorporated in guards, and facilities for making adjustments can be made accessible from outside the guards. As an aside, remember that the need for maintenance can be reduced by using higher-specification bearings and other components with higher reliability and a longer operating life.

Designers need to be wary of simply designing guards that meet the nominal requirements of the standards. Take, for example, BS EN ISO 13857, Safety of machinery - Safety distances to prevent hazard zones being reached by upper and lower limbs, which assumes that people will not use steps, chairs or other objects in an attempt to reach over guards; in reality, operators might well do so unless the guards are made sufficiently high or a top cover is installed.

Other hazards

In the vast majority of cases machine guards provide protection against moving parts of machinery - and these hazards cease to exist when the machine has stopped for maintenance. However, some machines also have hot surfaces, sharp edges or other hazards that continue to be present even when the moving parts are stationary. Designers should therefore take this into account when performing the risk assessment, designing the guards and providing measures such as warning signs and maintenance instructions. If necessary, additional physical guards can be provided to prevent accidental contact with sharp blades, for example.

BS EN ISO 13857 has already been mentioned, but there are numerous other standards relating to machine guarding (for more information, see On Your Guard - A Designer's Guide to Machinery Guarding Standards, which is available free of charge from Procter Machine Guarding). In addition, specific machine types are covered by C type standards that may contain detailed requirements relating to guarding. Designers therefore need to ensure that they are working to all of the applicable standards.

Clearly a thorough risk assessment and subsequent risk reduction measures by the machine designer can make a significant difference to the safety of maintenance operations, as can carefully prepared maintenance instructions. Nevertheless, maintenance managers still need to ensure that a risk assessment is undertaken before maintenance work is started. This is especially true if the machine has been modified or upgraded since the original instructions were prepared, or if the machine is getting old (the state of the art may have moved on since the instructions were prepared, so some procedures described in the instructions would no longer be regarded as adequately safe). In addition, fixed guards do not need to be interlocked so, if these need to be removed, lock-off procedures must be followed to ensure that the machine cannot be restarted.

Similarly, when the maintenance has been completed, procedures need to be followed to ensure that the guards have been replaced before the machine is restarted.

Access requirements

So far we have considered hazards relating to moving machinery, hot surfaces and sharp edges, but a considerable number of accidents occurring during machinery maintenance involve falls from height. Machine designers should consider whether suitable access is available for performing maintenance operations, or whether fixed access platforms should be installed. Indeed, end users are likely to find that fixed access platforms are cheaper in the long run than having to erect scaffolding structures each time maintenance is required.

Something else to consider in terms of machine guarding and safer maintenance is how to prevent access to the work area. With guards removed and potentially hazardous parts of machinery exposed, it is important to use signs, barriers or temporary perimeter guarding to prevent unauthorised access. This point is emphasised by the EU-OSHA in its campaign literature.

The idea of improving the safety of maintenance operations is not a new one; in 1985 the HSE published Deadly Maintenance - A Study of Fatal Accidents at Work and a separate report Deadly Maintenance - Plant and Machinery. The situation in the UK and Europe has improved since 1985, but there is still scope for further improvement. The foregoing explains the role that guarding plays in safer maintenance, with implications both for machine designers and those responsible for machinery maintenance.

Anyone interested in using better guard designs to make maintenance safer can follow the link to download a free copy of On Your Guard - A Designer's Guide to Machinery Guarding Standards.

Procter Machine Safety

11. Pantglas Industrial Estate
Bedwas
Caerphilly
CF83 8XD
UNITED KINGDOM

+44 (0)2920 855 758

mbinfo@machinesafety.co.uk

www.machinesafety.co.uk

More from Procter Machine Safety

Free updated Safety Distance Calculator tool, at the ready

Posted 2 weeks ago

Standards compliant guarding for new laser cutting machine

Posted 7 months ago

Procter releases free, updated safety distance and risk calculators

Posted 1 year ago

Procter Brothers Ltd announces Management Buyout

Posted 1 year ago

Satech BlueGuard stainless steel perimeter guarding from Procter

Posted 1 year ago

Free guide: machine guarding for waste management and recycling

Posted 1 year ago

What has changed in machine safety standard BS EN 60204-1:2018?

Posted 2 years ago

Updated guide to machinery safety standards

Posted 2 years ago

New range of safety and protection products from Procter

Posted 3 years ago

Machine risk assessment service from Procter Machine Safety

Posted 3 years ago

Bespoke acoustic enclosures from Procter Machine Safety

Posted 3 years ago

How ISO 12100 relates to type-B and type-C standards

Posted 3 years ago

Free email newsletter covers all aspects of machinery safety

Posted 3 years ago

Movie of the month

Posted 3 years ago

Procter Guide to Machinery Guarding Standards, 12th Edition

Posted 3 years ago

Machine risk assessment and PUWER inspection services

Posted 3 years ago

Movie of the month

Posted 3 years ago

Procter's new website incorporates machine guard e-shop

Posted 3 years ago

Procter apprentice wins Learner of the Year award

Posted 3 years ago

New machine risk assessment and PUWER services from Procter

Posted 3 years ago

Procter Bros apprentice shortlisted for prestigious EEF award

Posted 4 years ago

Darren Rhodes is new Managing Director of Procter Bros Group

Posted 4 years ago

Procter Machine Guarding wins BSIF customer service award

Posted 4 years ago

Procter Machine Guarding expert joins BSI standards committee

Posted 4 years ago

Movie of the month

Posted 4 years ago

High-quality machine guards designed, manufactured and installed

Posted 4 years ago

Free White Paper: benefits of acoustic enclosures for machines

Posted 4 years ago

Procter supports European Week for Safety and Health at Work

Posted 4 years ago

BS EN ISO 14122 download: free White Paper on machinery access

Posted 4 years ago

White Paper: machine guarding and PUWER assessments

Posted 5 years ago

Brexit implications for machine safety standards and regulations

Posted 5 years ago

Updated and expanded Guide to Machinery Guarding Standards

Posted 5 years ago

BS EN ISO 14123-1:2015, guarding against hazardous emissions

Posted 5 years ago

Movie of the month

Posted 5 years ago

Free download: EN 349 White Paper explains minimum gaps

Posted 5 years ago

Videos show impact tests on modular perimeter guarding

Posted 6 years ago

Free machine safety downloads from Procter Machine Guarding

Posted 6 years ago

Free White Paper explains requirements for conveyor guarding

Posted 6 years ago

Online guide to perimeter guarding for robots and robot cells

Posted 6 years ago

Movie of the month

Posted 6 years ago

Free download: PD 5304:2014 White Paper detailing changes

Posted 6 years ago

New video demonstrates Procter Machine Guarding's capabilities

Posted 6 years ago

The differences between guarding standards ISO 14120 and EN 953

Posted 6 years ago

Bosch Rexroth EcoSafe guarding now available from Procter

Posted 6 years ago

Is a drill guard necessary or can you rely on operator skill?

Posted 7 years ago

BS EN ISO 12100 Risk Assessment Calculator - video walkthrough

Posted 7 years ago

Movie of the month

Posted 7 years ago

EN ISO 13857 Safety Distance Calculator - video walkthrough

Posted 7 years ago

High-speed roller door provides rapid machine access

Posted 7 years ago

High-quality modular aluminium machine guarding from Procter

Posted 7 years ago

Ten things you need to know about machine guarding standards

Posted 7 years ago

How to specify a modular perimeter guarding system

Posted 7 years ago

Satech modular guarding system offers advantages for robot cells

Posted 7 years ago

Procter Machine Guarding installs workshop guards for Tata Steel

Posted 7 years ago

Free Guide to Machinery Guarding Standards, 10th Edition

Posted 7 years ago

Claim a free machinery safety memory stick at MACH

Posted 7 years ago

Fixings for fixed machine guards - further clarification

Posted 7 years ago

User-friendly list of machinery safety standards

Posted 7 years ago

How to design machine guards to deter defeating of interlocks

Posted 8 years ago

Free Guide to Machinery Guarding Standards, 9th Edition

Posted 8 years ago

Machinery safety standards listed on updated web page

Posted 8 years ago

New edition of Free White Paper: CE marking of machine guards

Posted 8 years ago

Procter named Preferred Provider of guarding by insurer QBE

Posted 8 years ago

New HSE advice on CE marking assemblies of machinery

Posted 9 years ago

Machine guarding - design and build or outsource?

Posted 9 years ago

Free download: BS EN ISO 12100:2010 Risk Assessment Calculator

Posted 9 years ago

Guards for Webster and Bennett vertical boring machines

Posted 10 years ago

Free guide to workshop safety - third edition now published

Posted 10 years ago

Custom-built guarding installed in automated warehouse

Posted 10 years ago

HSE reduces machine inspections, so users must do more

Posted 10 years ago

Modular perimeter guarding for automated high-bay warehouse

Posted 10 years ago

Nelsa guards brochure: free download

Posted 10 years ago

Nelsa standard machine shop guards available from Procter

Posted 10 years ago

Free guide to workshop safety - second edition published

Posted 11 years ago

Modular perimeter guarding is easily installed by customer

Posted 11 years ago

What does 'as low as reasonably practicable' mean?

Posted 11 years ago

Modular machine guarding system offers unlimited versatility

Posted 11 years ago

Procter publishes updated Guide to New Machinery Directive

Posted 11 years ago

Updated guide to machine guarding standards

Posted 11 years ago

Machine guarding pays for itself

Posted 11 years ago

CE marking machine guards to Machinery Directive 2006/42/EC

Posted 11 years ago

New machine guards for old machinery

Posted 12 years ago

Fixings for fixed guards: White Paper explains requirements

Posted 12 years ago

FREE guide to machinery guarding standards - new edition

Posted 12 years ago

Workshop Safety - a free guide to machine tool guarding

Posted 12 years ago

BS EN 953:1997 +A1:2009 - a review of the guarding standard

Posted 12 years ago

How to specify fasteners for fixed guards on machinery

Posted 12 years ago

FREE machine guarding compliance surveys

Posted 12 years ago

Procter to exhibit Nelsa machine shop guards

Posted 12 years ago

Free machinery safety CD-Rom at Safety & Health Expo

Posted 12 years ago

Procter and ISS Safety offer machinery safety service

Posted 12 years ago

Updated guide lists new machine guarding standards

Posted 13 years ago

Free download: EN ISO 13857 Safety Distance Calculator

Posted 13 years ago

ISO 13857, the standard for machinery safety distances

Posted 13 years ago

Safety of machinery: EN ISO 12100-1 and EN ISO 12100-2

Posted 13 years ago

Collect a free machinery safety CD-Rom at MACH 2008

Posted 13 years ago

Easy access to machinery safety information

Posted 13 years ago

Safeguarding machinery in compliance with BS 4163

Posted 13 years ago

Procter publishes guide to new Machinery Directive

Posted 13 years ago

Free kit of machinery safety guides and software tools

Posted 14 years ago

Free download: EN ISO 14121-1 machine risk assessment calculator

Posted 14 years ago

Free machine risk assessment calculator

Posted 14 years ago

How and why to specify cable ducting on machines

Posted 14 years ago

Free machine accident investigation kit - just in case...

Posted 14 years ago

Low-cost modular guarding can be installed by users

Posted 14 years ago

How to design guarding for food and drink machinery

Posted 14 years ago

New and updated machine safety standards

Posted 14 years ago

Review: PD 5304:2005 'Guidance on safe use of machinery'

Posted 14 years ago

How to cut the cost of machine tool enclosure guards

Posted 14 years ago

Free guide to machinery guarding standards

Posted 14 years ago

Free guide to machinery guarding standards (fourth edition)

Posted 14 years ago

More technical articles