Using energy-efficient electric motors to meet Energy Directives

Legislation on the minimum efficiency levels for AC electric motors has been in force since 2011. These regulations, often known in Europe as the ErP (Energy related Products) Directive, will become increasingly stringent over the next 10 years. The ultimate aim is to reduce the effects of industrial activities on the environment. As electric motors are responsible for 40 per cent of energy use in industrial nations, they are clearly an essential target in the process of reducing our carbon footprint.

The regulations

The European standard IEC60034-30:2008 defines three efficiency classes:

  • IE1 standard efficiency
  • IE2 high efficiency
  • IE3 premium efficiency

More recently IEC60034-31:2010 defined the efficiency levels for a higher motor standard IE4, "˜super premium'. As an example of the increasing efficiency levels, the minimum efficiency for a 4-pole 7.5kW motor running at rated load are: IE1 85 per cent; IE2 88 per cent; IE3 90.4 per cent; IE4 92.5 per cent.

Regulations are in force across most industrialised countries with similar definitions and efficiency levels. In the USA the EISA (Energy Independence and Security Act) applies. In China they have set the standard GB18613-2006. The European ErP Directive has set the following timescale for the introduction of efficient motors:

  • 16 June 2011 - motors must meet the IE2 efficiency level
  • 1 January 2015 - motors from 7.5 to 375kW must meet the higher IE3 efficiency level, or must be "˜equipped' with an inverter variable speed drive
  • 1 January 2017 - the 2015 regulations are extended down to motors of 0.75kW

Currently there is no timescale for the introduction of IE4 motors.

Scope and exceptions

The ErP Directive applies to AC asynchronous motors and geared motors in a power range 0.75-375kW. Motors can be 2, 4 or 6 pole, for operation at 50 or 60Hz and rated for continuous operation (S1 or S3). The Directive covers motors that are "˜placed on the market', that is, manufactured in or imported into the European Union. Effectively this means that all new motors sold must comply if they are within the scope and are to be installed in the EU. End-users are permitted to repair or rewind existing motors.

Current exceptions of brake motors, 8-pole motors and motors designed for extreme temperatures/altitudes are expected to be brought into the scope towards the end of 2013. There will remain a number of other exceptions, such as motors not designed to run at 50/50Hz, explosion proof/ATEX motors and those with a rated voltage above 1000V. However, the vast majority of industrial installations where the power is above 0.55kW will need to comply, either at the IE2 or the IE3 levels.

Drawbacks of higher-efficiency motors and alternative options

Manufacturing a motor with higher efficiently requires designs with more copper content and higher manufacturing precision. This in turn results in higher costs and, in some cases, significant increases in size. Justification of the higher purchase cost is usually straightforward: energy costs can amount to 90 per cent of the lifetime cost for electric motors and a 2-3 per cent saving can result in payback times of less than 2 years. So there is no good argument against the extra cost of high-efficiency electric motors. However, where the dimensions of the higher efficiency motor are bigger (they are often longer and in some cases one frame size bigger) there may be serious problems in upgrading machinery. Fortunately there are options to avoid larger dimensions that do not conflict with the regulations, and are also themselves energy efficient.

The use of a frequency inverter with an IE2 motor instead of an IE3 motor has already been mentioned. This avoids the potentially larger dimensions of the IE3 motor. Where the speed of the machine can be varied in response to demand, this is an excellent option. The ErP regulations are not specific about the way that IE2 motors should be "˜equipped' with an inverter. However it is clear that they do not need to be a single assembly (terminal box inverter) and can be purchased from different suppliers. Self-certification is likely to apply. A well-known application is fluid flow in pumps and fans. If the speed can be turned down to match low demand, large savings of even up to 80 per cent of energy costs are possible. Speed variation can easily be automated by PID controls in the inverter. Alternatively, where motors have to run at partial loads, Lenze offer software built into the 8400 series of inverters that can save up to 30 per cent of energy used.

Lenze's MF series of motors available from 0.55 to 22kW are rated to run with inverters at a setpoint of 120Hz. As such they fall outside the regulations and can be used without restriction. The higher power delivered at 120Hz leads to motor size reductions of one or even two frame sizes, and the performance comes with good efficiency, actually around the top end of IE2 levels. MF motors are available on their own or with a full range of gearboxes. They represent a good way of keeping small dimensions whilst complying with the ErP regulations.

New for 2014 is the Lenze Smart Motor, another product that is outside the regulations because it is not rated at 50Hz. This new drive available in 63 and 80 frame sizes is a combination of a standard motor with some clever electronics. It is designed for running at fixed speeds that can be adjusted and set using at smartphone app. The Lenze Smart Motor can be set to run at any speed from 500 to 2600r/min. With 400 per cent starting torque available, there is often saving of one frame size and actual running efficiency is high at IE3 levels.

Future introduction of the higher IE4 standard

Looking into the future, it is inevitable that the higher demands of IE4 efficiency levels will become law, although it is unlikely in this decade. To reach these high levels motor manufacturers have to move away from induction motors to permanent magnet, brushless servo and synchronous reluctance technologies. Manufacturing costs will step up sharply and again there will be dimension changes. For powers up to 15kW, efficient synchronous servo motors and geared motors are available now with the Lenze MCS range. Running efficiencies are in a range from 80 up to 94 per cent depending on power.

Whilst the inevitable escalation of electric motor efficiency regulations can be a headache for machine manufacturers, the end user gains with significantly lower lifetime operating costs. In some cases motors with higher efficiency will have larger dimensions. Where this is a problem there are existing systems based on electronic variable speed technology that can minimise motor size whilst also offering higher efficiency.

Please visit www.Lenze.com to learn more about energy-efficient electric motors.

Lenze Ltd

6 Abbey Court Road
Priory Business Park
Bedford
MK44 3WH
UNITED KINGDOM

+44 (0)1234 753200

sales.uk@lenze.com

www.lenze.com

More from Lenze Ltd

Optimise a drive in 60 seconds

Posted 3 days ago

Driving business together

Posted 5 days ago

Visualisation is your machine's business card

Posted 1 month ago

Lenze UK is all set with move to new facilities

Posted 1 month ago

From simulation to virtual commissioning

Posted 2 months ago

Intuitive user interfaces for smooth human-machine interaction

Posted 3 months ago

Ecodesign Directive just around the corner!

Posted 5 months ago

The clock is ticking!

Posted 5 months ago

In the machine building industry, the race is clearly speeding up: and success i

Posted 5 months ago

New motor energy efficiency rules are coming

Posted 6 months ago

Lenze rated as one of the best employers

Posted 7 months ago

Improving communication with (and between) machines

Posted 8 months ago

Webcast reveals advances made by machine builder

Posted 9 months ago

Lenze Live Webcast on conveyor cost reduction

Posted 9 months ago

Uniting the virtual and real world with a digital twin

Posted 10 months ago

Smart servo motion control comes with IIoT functions

Posted 11 months ago

Calculate conveying costs here

Posted 1 year ago

Lenze Smart Motor video is handy for conveyor designers

Posted 1 year ago

Lenze boss issues statement on cancellation of SPS 2020 fair

Posted 1 year ago

Smart Condition Monitoring: no additional measurement sensors

Posted 1 year ago

Free webcast: energy efficiency and the Ecodesign Directive

Posted 1 year ago

Lenze motors support compliance with Ecodesign Directive

Posted 1 year ago

Lenze launches weekly webcast series

Posted 1 year ago

Statement from Lenze following cancellation of Hannover Messe

Posted 1 year ago

Product of the month

Posted 1 year ago

Lenze: From idea to production

Posted 1 year ago

Lenze launches decentralised i500 frequency inverters

Posted 1 year ago

Lenze is ready for 2020 despite tough market conditions

Posted 1 year ago

Lenze improves market position and achieves revenue growth

Posted 1 year ago

Lenze's i550 protec drive has IP66 protection and IO-Link

Posted 1 year ago

Smart condition monitoring with no extra sensors

Posted 1 year ago

Next-generation controllers for Industry 4.0: IT meets OT

Posted 1 year ago

Lenze appoints Balz as Senior Vice President Automation Systems

Posted 1 year ago

Lenze's end-to-end tools and services for digital engineering

Posted 1 year ago

Lenze UK gains Authorised Economic Operator status

Posted 2 years ago

How machine builders can address the issue of single-use plastic

Posted 2 years ago

Choosing an automation partner for Industry 4.0

Posted 2 years ago

Grasping the opportunities afforded by Industry 4.0

Posted 2 years ago

Lenze to showcase mechatronic drive systems at IMHX exhibition

Posted 2 years ago

Lenze boosts drive and automation training offering

Posted 2 years ago

Lenze celebrates 50th anniversary in the UK

Posted 2 years ago

The smart, efficient option for driving horizontal conveyors

Posted 2 years ago

Lenze showcase logistics technology at Passenger Terminal Expo

Posted 2 years ago

Trend interview: Software engineering in drive technology

Posted 2 years ago

Freight logistics look for replicable material flow systems

Posted 2 years ago

Smart servo axis for effective and versatile production

Posted 2 years ago

How drives and automation meet the needs of modern warehouses

Posted 2 years ago

Digital services from OEMs

Posted 2 years ago

Logistics 4.0 is already reality

Posted 2 years ago

How to optimise handling systems for warehouses

Posted 2 years ago

Less is more: keeping complexity out of automation

Posted 2 years ago

The Lenze online advent calendar is back for 2018!

Posted 2 years ago

Lenze starts development of £44m Mechatronic Competence Campus

Posted 2 years ago

Lenze leads machine design into the future

Posted 3 years ago

Learn about the Lenze automation platform at PPMA Show

Posted 3 years ago

Lenze boosts training across its Drive & Automation platform

Posted 3 years ago

How to achieve cyber-security in a Smart Factory

Posted 3 years ago

Lenze to showcase its automation platform at Foodex 2018

Posted 3 years ago

How to choose an automation partner

Posted 3 years ago

Machine building, data, the IIoT and Industry 4.0

Posted 3 years ago

Top-three requirements for machine control systems

Posted 3 years ago

How to adopt modularisation in the Industry 4.0 era

Posted 3 years ago

The Lenze online Advent Calendar is back!

Posted 3 years ago

Lenze celebrates being a driving force in industry for 70 years

Posted 3 years ago

Lenze i950 Servo inverter: A new chapter in automation

Posted 3 years ago

Lenze Schmidhauser supports Formula Student Driverless

Posted 3 years ago

Study enhances materials handling performance and reliability

Posted 4 years ago

Technical article tackles warehouse automation challenge

Posted 4 years ago

Optimising machine automation in food and beverage manufacturing

Posted 4 years ago

Lenze presents recipes for the processing and packaging industry

Posted 4 years ago

Lenze team up with ei3 for secure data handling in the cloud

Posted 4 years ago

Five factors to consider when specifying automation

Posted 4 years ago

Compact and easy: the new m850 synchronous servo motors

Posted 4 years ago

Lenze's i500 inverter range WLAN module reaches awards final

Posted 4 years ago

Lenze demonstrates smart factory technology to Chancellor Merkel

Posted 4 years ago

Ready-to-go ErP-compliant motors and geared motors from Lenze

Posted 4 years ago

Lenze doubles torques of geared motors

Posted 4 years ago

Lenze i500 inverters available from local stockists

Posted 4 years ago

Lenze to launch all-in-one m350 Smart Gear at IntraLogisteX

Posted 4 years ago

The Lenze online Advent Calendar is back

Posted 4 years ago

Flexible machines to produce at batch size 1

Posted 4 years ago

Lenze introduces a new safety controller

Posted 4 years ago

Upgraded controller boasts more power but needs no cooling

Posted 4 years ago

Geared motor drives are preconfigured for faster installation

Posted 4 years ago

New electric car world record with Lenze inverters

Posted 4 years ago

New brochure for state-of-the-art Lenze i500 inverter drives

Posted 5 years ago

i500 inverter parameters easily set by smartphone

Posted 5 years ago

Energy recovery becomes more economic and easy

Posted 5 years ago

Lenze demonstrates integrated automation

Posted 5 years ago

Lenze introduces new online training concept

Posted 5 years ago

New Lenze inverters and gearmotors at Drives & Controls 2016

Posted 5 years ago

Lenze drives and control technology play key role in the theatre

Posted 5 years ago

How to set up an inverter drive in just 3, 5 or 7 minutes

Posted 5 years ago

New compact, low-cost, user-friendly Lenze inverter drives

Posted 5 years ago

800 prizes to be won!

Posted 5 years ago

Lenze Advent Calendar has over 800 prizes to be won!

Posted 5 years ago

Formula Student event includes Lenze-powered racing car

Posted 6 years ago

Servo technology increases air filter production by 70 per cent

Posted 6 years ago

Lenze's IE3 motors are easy to integrate

Posted 6 years ago

Gesture-controlled operating system for machine visualisation

Posted 6 years ago

Modernisation instead of a new production line

Posted 6 years ago

DC-bus connection makes energy saving easy

Posted 6 years ago

Panel building service provides benefits for machine builders

Posted 7 years ago

Easy access to Lenze controllers with OPC UA

Posted 7 years ago

5-axis robot for bank vault storage

Posted 7 years ago

New machine controllers are compact and cost-effective

Posted 7 years ago

Lenze drives in viastore storage & retrieval system

Posted 7 years ago

New Chief Executive Officer for Lenze SE

Posted 7 years ago

Aluminium geared motors offer exceptionally wide speed range

Posted 7 years ago

Precise carriage positioning using frequency inverter

Posted 7 years ago

Lenze's online Advent Calendar: 500 prizes to be won

Posted 7 years ago

New range of modular gearboxes with higher power density

Posted 7 years ago

Lenze Smart Motor speed is set using smartphone app

Posted 7 years ago

New drives for stenting machine

Posted 8 years ago

Added automation increases roof truss productivity

Posted 8 years ago

Lenze update PLC Designer with CoDeSys 3

Posted 8 years ago

High-speed I/O system suits real-time motion control

Posted 8 years ago

Decentralised inverter for larger plants

Posted 8 years ago

Lenze drive automation for Cornish brewery

Posted 8 years ago

Lenze i700 servo inverters now available for powers up to 15kW

Posted 8 years ago

Faster laminating through machine innovation

Posted 8 years ago

Easier drive installation with Lenze motec inverters

Posted 8 years ago

Lenze FAST software cuts machine development times

Posted 8 years ago

Drive Technology for automated warehouses

Posted 8 years ago

Bevel gearboxes - the modern replacement for worm gears

Posted 8 years ago

Inverters include energy-saving technology for no extra cost

Posted 9 years ago

Servo drive at the top of the 8400 frequency inverter range

Posted 9 years ago

White paper describes potential for huge savings in drive energy

Posted 9 years ago

High-performance servos deliver savings for machine builders

Posted 9 years ago

8400 motec terminal box inverters rated from 0.37 to 7.5kW

Posted 9 years ago

Inverters with PID control retrofitted to rope-winding machine

Posted 9 years ago

OKS surface protection system now available on servo motors

Posted 9 years ago

Lenze drives and motors simplify carpet recycling machine

Posted 9 years ago

IP65 SMV inverter drives are protected against UV and acid

Posted 9 years ago

Lenze I/O System 1000 gains functions and fieldbus couplers

Posted 9 years ago

Lenze 8400 series inverters offered with cold plate mounting

Posted 9 years ago

Lenze product catalogue available as free CD

Posted 9 years ago

Lenze automation system boosts packaging output by 20 per cent

Posted 10 years ago

Choosing the right technology for positioning applications

Posted 10 years ago

MF three-phase motors save space, energy and cost

Posted 10 years ago

Lenze expands its panel building and control systems business

Posted 10 years ago

Frequency inverters provide smooth starts and motion control

Posted 10 years ago

Controller integrates PLC logic, motion control, visualisation

Posted 10 years ago

Lenze SMV inverters gain new functions for machine applications

Posted 10 years ago

Servo drive safety module accepts single resolver input

Posted 10 years ago

TopLine inverters are cost-effective for servo applications

Posted 10 years ago

Frequency inverters run remote pumps from SWER supplies

Posted 10 years ago

Lenze Group announces results for 2009-10

Posted 10 years ago

Single-phase inverters used for prison van air conditioning

Posted 10 years ago

Lenze BlueGreen solutions deliver major energy savings

Posted 11 years ago

Miniature touchscreen HMI has the option of a Soft-PLC

Posted 11 years ago

Inverter-optimised motors save energy and are cheaper to buy

Posted 11 years ago

Lenze invests in logistics and new UK headquarters

Posted 11 years ago

Conveyor system inverter drives incorporate safety functions

Posted 11 years ago

IP65 inverter drives now available in power ratings up to 22kW

Posted 11 years ago

Lenze 8400 motec inverters mount on motors or panels

Posted 11 years ago

New I/O modules for EtherCAT, sensors and counters

Posted 11 years ago

Centraction selects IP65 sensorless vector drives

Posted 11 years ago

IP65 drives boost bakery productivity and quality

Posted 11 years ago

New range of energy-efficient IE2 geared motors

Posted 11 years ago

IP65 SMV inverter minimises wind tunnel downtime

Posted 11 years ago

Featured photo

Posted 11 years ago

Beer flows thanks to IP65 frequency inverters

Posted 11 years ago

IP65 inverter mounts on beer pump for filling casks

Posted 11 years ago

Aluminium worm geared motors selected for conveyors

Posted 11 years ago

Custom gearmotor cuts AGV cost and power consumption

Posted 11 years ago

Geared motors and brake motors with additional protection

Posted 11 years ago

L-force Logic & Motion gains Profibus option

Posted 11 years ago

Drives and automation CD catalogue contains 7000 pages

Posted 11 years ago

New modular L-force I/O system 1000 for real-time control

Posted 12 years ago

IP65 inverter drives can be used in direct sunlight

Posted 12 years ago

Inverters prevent motors burning out on emulsion pumps

Posted 12 years ago

Lenze offers help with machinery safety standards

Posted 12 years ago

Drive Solution Designer tool helps to save energy

Posted 12 years ago

IP65 inverters eliminate dust-related failures in food factory

Posted 12 years ago

Safety of machinery - a review of the guide from Lenze

Posted 12 years ago

Yoplait conveyors use 85 Lenze inverters and geared motors

Posted 12 years ago

Lenze offers soft-PLC option for EL100 touchscreen HMIs

Posted 12 years ago

Lenze servo motors specified for telescopic conveyors

Posted 12 years ago

Labelling machines use customised Lenze IPC and HMI

Posted 12 years ago

Lenze 9400 servo drives control curved motion profiles

Posted 12 years ago

How to cut the life cycle cost of automation projects

Posted 12 years ago

New models and features for Lenze 8400 inverters

Posted 12 years ago

Asynchronous servo motors offer economy and long life

Posted 12 years ago

IP65 inverter drive features integral isolator

Posted 12 years ago

Lenze 8400 HighLine inverters incorporate motion control

Posted 12 years ago

Free brochure outlines 'Energy saving solutions'

Posted 13 years ago

Power supplies save energy through regenerative braking

Posted 13 years ago

Touchscreen HMI range now available with built-in soft-PLC

Posted 13 years ago

PositionServo drive includes Ethernet as standard

Posted 13 years ago

Lenze systems house offers engineering and panel building

Posted 13 years ago

Free seminars on drives and automation

Posted 13 years ago

'Rightsize' modular drives deliver cost-effective functionality

Posted 13 years ago

Blowers boost power output of synchronous servo motors

Posted 13 years ago

Asynchronous servo motors now rated at up to 31.5kW

Posted 13 years ago

Lenze 9400 servo drives gain EtherCAT module option

Posted 13 years ago

Electronic cams provide exceptional dynamic performance

Posted 13 years ago

Drives bring improvements to corrugated board printers

Posted 14 years ago

Drives cope with water jets - and freezing in ice

Posted 14 years ago

Sensorless vector drives are easy to commission

Posted 14 years ago

Servo drive module handles multiple safety functions

Posted 14 years ago

More technical articles