What is a moving coil actuator?

In this, the first of several technical notes on moving coil actuators, Ed Neff, President of SMAC Moving Coil Actuators (MCA), provides a brief history of linear actuators and explains where moving coil actuators fit in.

Hydraulic actuators came first. These devices produce high forces and can because hydraulic fluids are not compressible. That means hydraulic actuators can operate as servo actuators, which is useful in applications that need variable speed and positioning. Primary uses are in the machine tool industry, plastic processing, and off-highway equipment. Speed is not high. Cost for hydraulic actuation is relatively high due to the need for power units and pumps. Typical life is about 10M cycles. Leakage of fluid is a major concern.

Pneumatic actuators (and valves) emerged after World War II. These devices produce low to medium forces and are relatively fast. However, pneumatic actuators are not typically useful as servo devices because of how their working fluid (air) is compressible, therefore difficult to employ for positioning. That means pneumatic cylinders essentially deliver two-position motion, and adjustments must be made manually. Typical life is about 10M cycles. Pneumatic actuators on their own are inexpensive; however, they do require the purchase of a compressor.

Electric actuators also emerged after World War II. The first of these devices (and many today) employ rotary motion from an electric motor that is converted to linear motion through some mechanism - often ball screws. Rotary motors are either open-loop steppers or closed-loop servo motors, with speed and position programmable on the latter. High speed is possible with wide screw pitch, although such geometry compromises speed and positioning precision. Cycle life is comparable to that of pneumatic cylinders. Electric actuators first replaced hydraulic actuators as mentioned above, but are now facing direct competition from linear motors because of the speed-precision tradeoff and cycle life. These devices cost about three times what pneumatic cylinders cost.

In the late 1980s, the first linear motor-based actuators began to appear. This was as a result of the development of high-strength magnets; first samarium cobalt and then neodymium. These DC devices include coils to move the portion of the assembly with magnets.

Linear-motor actuators are servo devices with programmable position and speed capabilities. They can have a much longer life (to 100M cycles) than air cylinders or ball screw actuators. To get relatively high speeds, the actuators need current to 5A+ range, this being needed because of the mass of the moving magnet. Force level is comparable to pneumatic devices. The price is about eight times that of pneumatic devices.

The moving-coil actuator

Image
In 2000, another linear motor was introduced to the market - the moving-coil actuator. The development of neodymium magnets is key to this device. In moving-coil actuators, the coils move and the magnets are static. These servo devices allow programmable control of position and velocity. They also allow programming of forces. Because the mover is a relatively light mass, these are the fastest linear actuators on the market. Just as moving magnet linear-motor actuators, moving-coil actuators also have long cycle life. Current input is in the 1.5A range owing to the low moving mass. Stroke is limited to about 500mm. Output force is comparable to that of pneumatic actuators. Price is about two to three times that of pneumatic actuators - and continues to drop.

Electric actuators have slowly replaced hydraulic actuators in about 70 per cent of applications, mostly for reasons related to cost, cycle life, and performance.

Image
Pneumatic actuators have been much harder to replace, mostly because of their low upfront cost. But that is changing. Consider electronic assembly, where pneumatic linear actuators have been almost completely replaced by ball screw or moving coil devices. In that industry, both cycle life and speed are critical - and price is not as important. Now, a similar change is occurring in the packaging industry. Here all three electric designs - ball screw, moving magnet, and moving coil - are replacing pneumatic actuators. Key reasons are eliminating the compressor, higher cycle life, programmable changeovers, and higher speed. Even so, cost is a key point, so lower-cost electric actuators will be needed to convert this industry completely.

That leads us to moving-coil actuators, which satisfy all these design objectives for new packaging-machine builds. Our next technical note will detail how a moving coil works and how fast it can go. Then we'll explain how actuator life is moving towards one billion cycles and why costs continue to drop.

Learn more at www.smac-mca.co.uk.

The second Technical Note in the series from SMAC can be read here: Innovations in moving-coil actuator technology.

SMAC Moving Coil Actuators

Ikon House
Rutherford Way
Crawley
RH10 9PB
UNITED KINGDOM

+44 (0)1293 520147

info@smac-mca.com

www.smac-mca.co.uk

More from SMAC Moving Coil Actuators

Innovations in moving-coil actuator technology

Posted 1 year ago

Stackable linear actuators are fast and cost-competitive

Posted 1 year ago

SMAC wins business manufacturing high capacity EV batteries

Posted 2 years ago

SMAC introduces GUI for thread checking and other apps

Posted 2 years ago

SMAC electric actuator doubles pneumatic actuator eject speed

Posted 3 years ago

Smart Screwdrivers combine control and monitoring functions

Posted 3 years ago

SMAC Moving Coil Actuators introduces Tech Niches

Posted 3 years ago

Programmable micro gripper for handling small, fragile parts

Posted 3 years ago

SMAC introduces 'world's thinnest moving coil linear motor'

Posted 3 years ago

CBL50: expansion of the CBL series electric cylinder from SMAC

Posted 5 years ago

CBL35C series electric cylinder with built-in controller

Posted 6 years ago

SLA25: precision linear slide with cross-roller guide

Posted 6 years ago

SMAC introduces high-performance CBL Series electric cylinders

Posted 6 years ago

Cost-effective electric cylinder delivers high performance

Posted 11 years ago

Posted 11 years ago

New SMAC website for moving-coil actuators

Posted 12 years ago

Miniature electric actuators feature integral feedback

Posted 12 years ago

Compact gripper for handling and measuring applications

Posted 12 years ago

Fully automated system checks screw threads

Posted 12 years ago

Moving coil actuator sorts parts at ultra-high speeds

Posted 13 years ago

Moving coil actuators selected for switch test applications

Posted 13 years ago

Electric actuators are direct replacements for pneumatics

Posted 13 years ago

Actuator delivers benefits of electronics and pneumatics

Posted 13 years ago

High-speed gripper incorporates high-precision measurement

Posted 13 years ago

SMAC develops ultra-high-speed pick-and-place

Posted 13 years ago

More technical articles
21 hours ago
High-quality UK made ABS power supply cases
13A Plug-in and In-line styles from BCL Enclosures includes flame-retardant ABS models
1 day ago
Variohm Group buys Phoenix America
Based in Fort Wayne, Indiana ,Phoenix offers a range of absolute and incremental encoders, together with speed and proximity sensors, custom moulded magnets and more
1 day ago
New chain configurator aids machine builders
Tsubaki's recently unveiled configurator can make specifying chain a whole lot quicker and easier
1 day ago
Counterfeit bearings – NSK continues the fight against the fakes
The scale of the fake bearings problem has been highlighted with the discovery of around 23,000 counterfeit NSK packages and labels at a plant in Hebei Province, China
1 day ago
Parker launches new hydraulic fluid particle contamination monitor
The company’s icount LaserCM30 Particle Contamination Monitor is now available and can provide test results in 90 seconds
2 days ago
Last few places on Machinery Safety Course
Just a handful of places remain available on the last Pilz City & Guilds accredited Machinery Safety Course in 2020. Diary date is December 14th to 17th
2 days ago
Camozzi Automation launches new quick exhaust safety valves
Designed to provide a plug and play solution for OEMs that need to be compliant with Machinery Directive 2006/42/EC, Camozzi Automation says that its new quick exhaust 2-way safety valve range also complies with ISO 13849-1 covering the safe design of control systems which perform safety functions
2 days ago
SICK’s Open Service for IO-Link function blocks
A new open software service for control systems has been introduced by SICK
5 days ago
Automatic bearing lubrication brings ore inspiring results in mining
By installing automatic lubricators for bearings on its conveyor drive motors and belt pulleys, an opencast mine in Hungary has seen a range of benefits, including the prevention of unplanned downtime, longer bearing life and reduced repair work
5 days ago
Kinoulton company conveys COVID-combating masks
Here's a great example of the germ of an idea resulting in the combating of COVID