What is the best type of robot controller?

The current trend of robot control is changing with PLC-based systems offering different benefits and opportunities over the traditional dedicated robot controllers. So what needs to be considered when selecting the right option for the application? Barry Weller, Product Manager at Mitsubishi Electric, looks at how to determine which robot control option is best.

While it may look like a relatively simple choice, selecting a robot control system greatly influences the overall machine capabilities and ease of set-up and operation. Getting it right can help improve system flexibility, avoid compromising performance and productivity, plus simplifying commissioning for machine builders and integrators, whilst minimising changeover time for operators.

By following a few best practices and principles, users can be sure to select a control option that meets the requirements of a given application whilst maximising productivity and Return On Investment (ROI).

PLC-based control options can help build a tailor-made system

With a number of current PLC or motion control products, such as the Mitsubishi Electric iQ-R, the kinematics to control many different types of system are available. This enables an Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) to design and build a bespoke robotic system; for example, a 2-axis gantry pick and place or a 4-axis delta arm for packaging.

While dedicated robot controllers provide off-the-shelf options that are suitable for a wide range of applications, PLC-based control options can empower robot integrators to develop their own bespoke systems.

There is an argument that suggests that designing a bespoke system may offer a price advantage as it is often less expensive to buy a kit of parts and build the system from scratch than invest in a traditional robot arm. Indeed, this may suit an OEM with multiple systems to build and would probably show cost savings. Of course, the application will determine the best approach but designing in this way can allow an OEM to create a tailor-made product.

An example of an application like this would be the control of a bakery tin store. The motion profile of this application is a very simple pick-and-place operation with maybe 2 or 3 axes of control; however, the mechanics can be physically very large, having to span tens of metres of the store. Using the built-in kinematics of the iQ-R PLC system, the setup times and programming of the control system can be reduced, as the tin positions can be taught or the co-ordinates calculated in the control system.

This system also allows other axes to be easily integrated into the system; for example, the system could be expanded to include the control of the delivery system, bringing the tins into, or away from, the store.

When should you opt for dedicated robot controllers?

Choosing a PLC-based robot control option may seem like the most cost-effective way to go. Yet, it is important to consider the design time of the mechanical system, the flexibility required from the manufacturing cell, the cell footprint and also the configuration and engineering time. This is taken care of by selecting an off the shelf dedicated robotic system. A typical 4-axis SCARA (Selective Compliance Articulated Robot Arm) system, for instance, can now be supplied at a very competitive cost. The robot mechanical system is already designed and its CAD model can be imported into the machine design, saving time and cost. When the system is being built the robot is also simple to install and needs just four bolts to mount it into a machine and can be programmed in less than an hour to do a simple operation.

The controllers contain hundreds of dedicated instructions that make the more complex functions, such as tracking a product along a moving conveyor or complying with an external force, easy to integrate as they are already built into the system.

Further benefits come when machine safety is considered. Dedicated robot controllers have to conform to industry standards that cover their design, which include safety. This means that it is much easier for the system designer to achieve an integrated safety system for the total machine by using compliant components.

Many alternatives, one comprehensive provider

If the choice between dedicated or PLC-based robot control is still in the balance, then of course manufacturers that provide both such as Mitsubishi Electric can support machine builders and robot integrators alike in selecting the most suitable alternative. Customers can choose between state-of-the-art PLCs and dedicated robot controllers to match the requirements of their systems.

The company offers advanced MELFA robot controllers, which allow users to programme the robots by using the powerful Mitsubishi Electric RT-Toolbox engineering environment. When PLC-based control is preferred, Mitsubishi Electric's iQ Monozukuri Handling Suite empowers users to take control of movement and information management tasks. The suite features a handling application package and a control program that connects the MELSEC iQ-R PLC series of high-performance and scalable controllers with robots, HMIs and other compatible automation components.

In addition, when the best of both systems is needed, Mitsubishi Electric offers the unique option of integrating a dedicated robot controller directly into the PLC rack. The controller is compatible with the company's iQ modular PLC platform, which can seamlessly integrate a range of different functional controllers along with I/O and networking options.

In the end, the control requirements and the physical attributes of the application often dictate which option is best but for machine builders and integrators alike, it would be sensible to adopt a flexible, integrated automation system that offered choice and scalability.

Learn more at gb3a.mitsubishielectric.com.

Mitsubishi Electric Europe B.V.

Travellers Lane
AL10 8XB

+44 (0)1707 288780



More technical articles
2 hours ago
Mouser Electronics receives TDK’s top distribution awards
Mouser Electronics has received three top distribution awards from TDK. Mouser was honoured with TDK’s Global Best Performance Award for Fiscal Year 2022, North America Distributor of the Year for Calendar Year 2021, and European Distribution Award in High-Service Distribution for 2021.
12 hours ago
White Paper addresses assembly challenges
Resolve assembly challenges instantly with Henkel’s new high performance LOCTITE 402, an innovative instant adhesive that also improves workplace safety. Download the all-new white paper here.
21 hours ago
Schaeffler organises worldwide Climate Action Day
June has seen Climate Action Day at all Schaeffler locations worldwide, with every one of the approximate 83,000 Schaeffler Group employees stopping work for 90 minutes to focus on climate issues.
1 day ago
Yokogawa helps Solar Team Twente to solar challenge win
Yokogawa’s WT5000 precision power analyser has been used by Solar Team Twente to win the first ever Solar Challenge Morocco. The WT5000 helped the team to squeeze every last watt out of its car’s solar power system, ensuring it crossed the finish line of the 2,500 km course in first place.
1 day ago
HVACR OEM relies on Emka locking technology
When HVACR OEM Hansa Klimasysteme needed new connecting elements for the corners of its air-conditioning units to stabilise the housing cube, suitable for die-casting, it turned to Emka.
1 day ago
LEM holds inauguration ceremony for new production plant
Electrical measurement specialist LEM has held an inauguration ceremony in Penang, Malaysia for its new production plant. The ceremony marked a major step in the plant’s construction with the first electric current sensor products expected to come on-line in Q1 2024.
2 days ago
ITI acquires digital manufacturing specialist Cimlogic
ITI, one of the UK’s largest independent systems integrators, has acquired Cimlogic, a leading digital manufacturing solutions and services provider to some of the world’s largest manufacturers.
2 days ago
Atlas Copco saves precision sheet metal manufacturer over £6,000 a month
When Constant Group, a Manchester-based supplier of sheet metal parts, components, and fully assembled fabrications pieces were let down by their previous service provider for onsite high-pressure nitrogen generation, they turned to Atlas Copco for help.
3 days ago
Timber plant reduces downtime with NSK linear guides
Thanks to the adoption of NSK’s linear guides with K1 lubrication units, a timber manufacturer managed to reduce conveyor downtime by a factor of more than 12, prompting annual cost savings of more than €77,000.
3 days ago
Renishaw announces investment of over £50 million for UK site
Renishaw is to invest over £50 million at its Miskin site in South Wales to increase manufacturing capacity and to help meet its Net Zero emissions targets.

Login / Sign up