White paper: is it better to build or buy linear actuators?

This White Paper from Misumi considers the various options available to engineers sourcing a single-axis linear actuator and discusses whether it is better to build a unit from discrete components or buy one ready-assembled.

Whether they are termed single-axis actuators, linear guides, slides or tables, all the products discussed in this paper provide the same generic function - namely precision linear motion of a load in a single axis - as part of a machine, item of equipment, assembly line or testing device.

Various linear motion devices are available today for single-axis movement, whether it be for an assembly operation, testing, packaging or simple motion control. This white paper seeks to define the various types and the options to be considered when deciding whether to build or buy a single-axis actuator.

Over the years, the technology has improved, the motions have become more precisely controlled and the materials of construction have evolved to suit the particular needs of various industries. Automotive and appliance assembly first utilised linear motion devices nearly 100 years ago, though the principle dates back to the days when manpower was used to engage the pulleys manipulating the building blocks for pyramids. Many credit al-Jaziri in the 13th century, with his invention of the crankshaft, as the first to apply rotary motion to produce linear, reciprocating motion - which is the foundation of what we address in this paper.

Whether controlled by hydraulics, electro-mechanics, electro-magnetics, vacuum or other means, the principle is the same. Paramount is the need for precise yet fast motion control, while remaining as friction-free as possible, with the minimum of mechanical wear and highly repeatable positioning. Dozens of manufacturers offer such products, in a variety of sizes, styles and materials, for today's machine designers. In this paper we will address the advantages and disadvantages of some of the most popular electric motor-driven styles, then address the main focus of this paper, which is the decision about when to build versus when to buy a single-axis actuator to suit the particular application at hand.

Several of the most common types of motorised linear actuators are:

  • Ball screw-driven and ball-guided units - best suited for high-thrust, heavy-load, precision positioning and stiffness
  • Ball screw-driven and single-guided units - lower in cost and suitable for harsh operating environments where contaminants are presents
  • Belt-driven and ball-guided units - offer a long use life and smooth operation, plus higher speeds, acceleration and accommodation of medium payloads
  • Belt-driven and slide-guided units - low maintenance and high-speed performance, plus smooth, quiet operation under acceleration

Depending upon the industry of application, various factors will determine the most suitable style to be used. Automotive, appliance, packaging, medical, semiconductor, general assembly/test and factory automation applications all take different factors into account in the decision-making process for the right operating mode, materials, performance and ambient noise conditions to be selected. Furthermore, the cost factors are driven by the availability of standard or easily customised standard product, the quantities required for the application, the ability of the resident engineering talent to design and build, plus the immediacy of need involved.

For a unit to be built, the engineer must calculate the forces, loads and tolerance build-up for each component used in the unit. This is true, regardless of the operational mode selected, of course. In addition, the engineer must calculate the use life of each component, the fit, the function, the durability and the maintenance requirements of each component. Certain industries such as medical and semiconductor, where the unit will function in a clean-room or other highly controlled environment, will mandate the use of certain grades of construction materials, which may or may not be readily available from the traditional component manufacturers. And, if they are available, the performance of the component may not meet the force, load and mechanical specifications of the application. These would include, but not be limited to, the correct size, speed, accuracy, stroke and load-bearing characteristics, as well as the finish and lubricant compatibility for certain industries such as food, medical and semiconductor, where particulate migration is a key consideration.

Purchasing considerations

In purchasing a unit, the size, speed, accuracy, positioning repeatability, load, stroke and other feature information are sometimes provided at the unit level, not the component level. Thus, an immediate time saving is realised in the evaluation process. Additionally, the engineer not only saves time on the design, but also finds savings by eliminating the need to investigate if the standard components available on the market can properly fit together. The engineer must still take into consideration the functional durability of the unit overall, its lifespan in the particular application, its maintenance requirements and its availability. However, these questions can usually be answered very quickly, either by catalogue documentation online or, yes, even the traditional phone call to a knowledgeable applications engineer.

The engineer must still choose the correct size, speed, accuracy, load, stroke and motor compatibility for the job. When a selection is made, the advanced unit suppliers today will have native CAD files ready for downloading in various formats to suit the engineer's platform, with the most sophisticated now offering a configurable design option online. This function enables selectable modifications to be made, often without surcharge, to the standard catalogued items. Thus, the engineer realises the triple benefit of cost containment, substantial time savings and the elimination of outside machining or in-house shop utilisation to make modifications before final assembly into the end product or manufacturing operation.

As pricing is always a consideration, whether building semiconductors or screwdrivers, the decision to build or buy takes this critical factor into the calculation, but in different ways.

When pricing the build of a linear motion unit, there is the obvious expense of buying individual components separately from various vendors, with the attendant paperwork. Typically, the following components would be required for a single-axis, motor-driven, ball screw actuator with 340mm base length, 150mm table width and 12mm lead screw diameter, able to handle a vertical load of approximately 140kg, with the approximate costs shown for each component, based on published prices online today:

  • Ball Screw £150
  • Guide £270
  • Support unit, fixed side £50
  • Support unit, motion side £30
  • Table £55
  • Nut bracket £40
  • Motor bracket £80
  • Stopper (bumpers) £15
  • Base, machined aluminium £440
  • Design time (£40/hr for 21 hrs) £840
  • Assembly time £40
  • Inspection time £40

TOTAL = £2050

In contrast, buying a unit, especially one configured online, requires only the selection of the most cost-effective system. Since the maintenance of a purchased unit is generally lower, given the reliable manufacturing of reputable suppliers, the long-term cost reduces. Plus, the predictable published cost (approximately half the above price) provides easier budgeting, there are minimal design costs for the unit (once the specifications are entered into the configurator, the CAD file can be downloaded) and, on a practical but important level for the procurement process, there is just one vendor, one price, one purchase order, one part number and one order to follow. If the unit selected is appropriate for the application, this scenario is clearly desirable.

Delivery times

In terms of the time required to execute a build versus buy, the build route clearly requires multiple lead times from multiple vendors. Additionally, there is the internal engineering time for the selection of components, an assembly drawing, component drawings, order placement, shipping, assembly into production and inspection. Such a project can typically take several weeks up to several months, depending on the complexity of the components chosen. For the buy route, the predictable delivery schedule for a single finished unit allows greater control over the machine build time management. Be cautious, though, because while a single vendor means just one lead time for the unit, many suppliers will have a back order log that delays the delivery substantially. Plus, many suppliers will build a custom unit to suit your application, but the lead time might be eight to twelve weeks and therefore delay the completion of the machine, test station, pick-and-place system or robotic handling line.

In the end, the decision to build or buy requires consideration of many factors, as well as an honest assessment of the resident engineering and machine shop resources at your company. In many cases and in most industries, the available products from vendors today will represent a time-saving, cost-saving and far more reliable alternative for linear motion requirements. Those pyramid builders were not inclined to outsource, it is true, but their projects did take lifetimes and longer to complete, a scenario that is somewhat impractical today, to say the least.

Visit Misumi's website at www.misumi-europe.com for more information and to request catalogues.

Misumi Europa GmbH

Franklinstrasse 61-63
60486 Frankfurt am Main
GERMANY

+49 69 668173 0

sales@misumi-europe.com

https://uk.misumi-ec.com/

More from Misumi Europa GmbH

MISUMI launches European production of MTO components

Posted 1 week ago

One-stop shopping at Misumi: over 800 partner brands available

Posted 1 year ago

Misumi has new head of sales and marketing

Posted 7 years ago

Ordering and delivery service for parts and parts from drawings

Posted 7 years ago

eCatalogue for customised standard components from Misumi

Posted 7 years ago

Custom-made components with no small-volume surcharge

Posted 8 years ago

New from Misumi: Conveyors

Posted 8 years ago

Customised steel shafts in over one billion configurations

Posted 9 years ago

Misumi offers high-quality contact and positioning switches

Posted 9 years ago

Standard precision positioning stages feature in new brochure

Posted 9 years ago

Misumi launches standard precision positioning stages

Posted 9 years ago

Misumi Product Highlights 2011

Posted 9 years ago

Misumi appoints new Country Sales Manager for the UK

Posted 9 years ago

Misumi catalogues and information now available on DVD

Posted 9 years ago

Trapezoidal screw drive components and assemblies

Posted 9 years ago

Linear units offered with more options for lengths and motors

Posted 9 years ago

New models and lower prices for toggle clamps

Posted 11 years ago

Magnetic drives provide non-contact power transmission

Posted 11 years ago

Misumi launches 2011/12 catalogue of automation components

Posted 11 years ago

Misumi launches 24/7 Web Ordering System (WOS)

Posted 11 years ago

Misumi offers wider choice of linear motion units

Posted 11 years ago

Extensive range of linear guides for factory automation

Posted 11 years ago

Locating pins in a variety of sizes and styles

Posted 12 years ago

Configurable rollers feature in 2008 catalogue

Posted 12 years ago

Location components in a range of sizes and specifications

Posted 12 years ago

Miniature linear guides can be configured to order

Posted 12 years ago

New ranges of configurable XY stages

Posted 12 years ago

How configurable components help machine builders

Posted 12 years ago

New family of Misumi self-lubricating linear bushings

Posted 12 years ago

Free catalogue of standard components for factory automation

Posted 12 years ago

Custom-configured shafts available on short delivery times

Posted 12 years ago

See Misumi's configured-to-order parts at the MB show

Posted 12 years ago

Free seminars demonstrate benefits of online parts configurator

Posted 12 years ago

Press manufacturer sources parts from Misumi

Posted 12 years ago

Custom-configured components save time and cost

Posted 12 years ago

Single-axis actuator is configured to order in 11 days

Posted 13 years ago

Misumi helps DTI cut machine design and build costs

Posted 13 years ago

Online shop enables machine builders to buy custom parts

Posted 13 years ago

70,000 standard parts, plus customisation and CAD

Posted 13 years ago

CAD portal offers 2D/3D CAD files and other facilities

Posted 13 years ago

Misumi invests in European operations

Posted 13 years ago

Misumi to Exhibit on Stand C49 at Machine Building show

Posted 13 years ago

More technical articles
13 hours ago
New autoglide 5 system from igus doesn’t need a guide trough
A new energy chain system for intralogistics and crane systems has been designed by motion plastics experts igus
13 hours ago
New DC/AC converter unveiled by Phoenix Contact
With the arrival of its new DC/AC inverter (part of the Phoenix Contact Quint Power family) the company says that machine builders now have a compact solution to generate alternating current in DC applications
13 hours ago
New-generation bullet train runs on NSK bearings
High-performance bearings from NSK are now operational in the newly developed N700S Shinkansen (bullet train)
1 day ago
New power supply unit from WAGO
PRO 2 is said to offer machine and panel builders a flexible, efficient and future proofed solution for a range of applications
1 day ago
Visual indication from IP69K compression latch
EMKA has introduced a stainless steel IP69K compression latch that offers users a visual status indication
2 days ago
New fast delivery service for industrial gear units
SEW Eurodrive has launched a new service providing rapid delivery of industrial gear units
2 days ago
Intelliconnect awarded two new ISO Accreditations
UK manufacturing facility is now approved to ISO 14001 and ISO 45001
5 days ago
Machine safety update: News from Pilz
Pilz has introduced a new PITgatebox and PITreader pushbutton control unit featuring an access permission system
5 days ago
Hygienic desk protection screens from Minitec
The company says it has been putting its popular profile systems to good use during the pandemic, creating essential screening products for use across both industry and retail sites alike
5 days ago
Powerful but compact new board for today’s big computing applications
PICO-WHU4 - designed for developers and system integrators of powerful applications